diff --git a/lucene/spatial3d/src/java/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/Plane.java b/lucene/spatial3d/src/java/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/Plane.java
index 6cef2d8528f..5917ce7af3c 100755
--- a/lucene/spatial3d/src/java/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/Plane.java
+++ b/lucene/spatial3d/src/java/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/Plane.java
@@ -1359,8 +1359,6 @@ public class Plane extends Vector {
       // m * [- 2*A*ab^2*r + 2*A^2*ab^2*r*q + 2*B^2*ab^2*r*q + 2*C^2*c^2*r*q] +
       // [ab^2 - 2*A*ab^2*q + A^2*ab^2*q^2 + B^2*ab^2*q^2 + C^2*c^2*q^2]  =  0
       
-      //System.err.println("    computing X bound");
-      
       // Useful subexpressions for this bound
       final double q = A*abSquared*k;
       final double qSquared = q * q;
@@ -1400,29 +1398,33 @@ public class Plane extends Vector {
           assert Math.abs(a * m1 * m1 + b * m1 + c) < MINIMUM_RESOLUTION;
           final double m2 = (-b - sqrtResult) * commonDenom;
           assert Math.abs(a * m2 * m2 + b * m2 + c) < MINIMUM_RESOLUTION;
-          final double l1 = r * m1 + q;
-          final double l2 = r * m2 + q;
-          // x = ((1 - l*A) * ab^2 ) / (2 * m)
-          // y = (-l*B * ab^2) / ( 2 * m)
-          // z = (-l*C * c^2)/ (2 * m)
-          final double denom1 = 0.5 / m1;
-          final double denom2 = 0.5 / m2;
-          final GeoPoint thePoint1 = new GeoPoint((1.0-l1*A) * abSquared * denom1, -l1*B * abSquared * denom1, -l1*C * cSquared * denom1);
-          final GeoPoint thePoint2 = new GeoPoint((1.0-l2*A) * abSquared * denom2, -l2*B * abSquared * denom2, -l2*C * cSquared * denom2);
-          //Math is not quite accurate enough for this
-          //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint1): "Point1: "+thePoint1+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
-          //  (thePoint1.x*thePoint1.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.y*thePoint1.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.z*thePoint1.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
-          //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint2): "Point1: "+thePoint2+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
-          //  (thePoint2.x*thePoint2.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.y*thePoint2.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.z*thePoint2.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
-          //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint1): "Evaluation of point1: "+evaluate(thePoint1);
-          //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint2): "Evaluation of point2: "+evaluate(thePoint2);
-          addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint1);
-          addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint2);
+          if (Math.abs(m1) >= MINIMUM_RESOLUTION || Math.abs(m2) >= MINIMUM_RESOLUTION) {
+            final double l1 = r * m1 + q;
+            final double l2 = r * m2 + q;
+            // x = ((1 - l*A) * ab^2 ) / (2 * m)
+            // y = (-l*B * ab^2) / ( 2 * m)
+            // z = (-l*C * c^2)/ (2 * m)
+            final double denom1 = 0.5 / m1;
+            final double denom2 = 0.5 / m2;
+            final GeoPoint thePoint1 = new GeoPoint((1.0-l1*A) * abSquared * denom1, -l1*B * abSquared * denom1, -l1*C * cSquared * denom1);
+            final GeoPoint thePoint2 = new GeoPoint((1.0-l2*A) * abSquared * denom2, -l2*B * abSquared * denom2, -l2*C * cSquared * denom2);
+            //Math is not quite accurate enough for this
+            //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint1): "Point1: "+thePoint1+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
+            //  (thePoint1.x*thePoint1.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.y*thePoint1.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.z*thePoint1.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
+            //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint2): "Point1: "+thePoint2+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
+            //  (thePoint2.x*thePoint2.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.y*thePoint2.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.z*thePoint2.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
+            //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint1): "Evaluation of point1: "+evaluate(thePoint1);
+            //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint2): "Evaluation of point2: "+evaluate(thePoint2);
+            addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint1);
+            addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint2);
+          } else {
+            // This is a plane of the form A=n B=0 C=0.  We can set a bound only by noting the D value.
+            boundsInfo.addXValue(-D/A);
+          }
         } else {
           // No solutions
         }
       } else if (Math.abs(b) > MINIMUM_RESOLUTION_SQUARED) {
-        //System.err.println("Not x quadratic");
         // a = 0, so m = - c / b
         final double m = -c / b;
         final double l = r * m + q;
@@ -1569,24 +1571,29 @@ public class Plane extends Vector {
           assert Math.abs(a * m1 * m1 + b * m1 + c) < MINIMUM_RESOLUTION;
           final double m2 = (-b - sqrtResult) * commonDenom;
           assert Math.abs(a * m2 * m2 + b * m2 + c) < MINIMUM_RESOLUTION;
-          final double l1 = r * m1 + q;
-          final double l2 = r * m2 + q;
-          // x = (-l*A * ab^2 ) / (2 * m)
-          // y = ((1.0-l*B) * ab^2) / ( 2 * m)
-          // z = (-l*C * c^2)/ (2 * m)
-          final double denom1 = 0.5 / m1;
-          final double denom2 = 0.5 / m2;
-          final GeoPoint thePoint1 = new GeoPoint(-l1*A * abSquared * denom1, (1.0-l1*B) * abSquared * denom1, -l1*C * cSquared * denom1);
-          final GeoPoint thePoint2 = new GeoPoint(-l2*A * abSquared * denom2, (1.0-l2*B) * abSquared * denom2, -l2*C * cSquared * denom2);
-          //Math is not quite accurate enough for this
-          //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint1): "Point1: "+thePoint1+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
-          //  (thePoint1.x*thePoint1.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.y*thePoint1.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.z*thePoint1.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
-          //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint2): "Point2: "+thePoint2+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
-          //  (thePoint2.x*thePoint2.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.y*thePoint2.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.z*thePoint2.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
-          //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint1): "Evaluation of point1: "+evaluate(thePoint1);
-          //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint2): "Evaluation of point2: "+evaluate(thePoint2);
-          addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint1);
-          addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint2);
+          if (Math.abs(m1) >= MINIMUM_RESOLUTION || Math.abs(m2) >= MINIMUM_RESOLUTION) {
+            final double l1 = r * m1 + q;
+            final double l2 = r * m2 + q;
+            // x = (-l*A * ab^2 ) / (2 * m)
+            // y = ((1.0-l*B) * ab^2) / ( 2 * m)
+            // z = (-l*C * c^2)/ (2 * m)
+            final double denom1 = 0.5 / m1;
+            final double denom2 = 0.5 / m2;
+            final GeoPoint thePoint1 = new GeoPoint(-l1*A * abSquared * denom1, (1.0-l1*B) * abSquared * denom1, -l1*C * cSquared * denom1);
+            final GeoPoint thePoint2 = new GeoPoint(-l2*A * abSquared * denom2, (1.0-l2*B) * abSquared * denom2, -l2*C * cSquared * denom2);
+            //Math is not quite accurate enough for this
+            //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint1): "Point1: "+thePoint1+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
+            //  (thePoint1.x*thePoint1.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.y*thePoint1.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint1.z*thePoint1.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
+            //assert planetModel.pointOnSurface(thePoint2): "Point2: "+thePoint2+"; Planetmodel="+planetModel+"; A="+A+" B="+B+" C="+C+" D="+D+" planetfcn="+
+            //  (thePoint2.x*thePoint2.x*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.y*thePoint2.y*planetModel.inverseAb*planetModel.inverseAb + thePoint2.z*thePoint2.z*planetModel.inverseC*planetModel.inverseC);
+            //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint1): "Evaluation of point1: "+evaluate(thePoint1);
+            //assert evaluateIsZero(thePoint2): "Evaluation of point2: "+evaluate(thePoint2);
+            addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint1);
+            addPoint(boundsInfo, bounds, thePoint2);
+          } else {
+            // This is a plane of the form A=0 B=n C=0.  We can set a bound only by noting the D value.
+            boundsInfo.addYValue(-D/B);
+          }
         } else {
           // No solutions
         }
diff --git a/lucene/spatial3d/src/test/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/GeoCircleTest.java b/lucene/spatial3d/src/test/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/GeoCircleTest.java
index 6f9a86b5d23..0190cde7f02 100755
--- a/lucene/spatial3d/src/test/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/GeoCircleTest.java
+++ b/lucene/spatial3d/src/test/org/apache/lucene/spatial3d/geom/GeoCircleTest.java
@@ -405,4 +405,18 @@ public class GeoCircleTest extends LuceneTestCase {
     assertTrue(solid.isWithin(gp));
   }
   
+  @Test
+  public void testBoundsFailureCase2() {
+    final GeoCircle gc = GeoCircleFactory.makeGeoCircle(PlanetModel.WGS84, -2.7574435614238194E-13, 0.0, 1.5887859182593391);
+    final GeoPoint gp = new GeoPoint(PlanetModel.WGS84, 0.7980359504429014, 1.5964981068121482);
+    final XYZBounds bounds = new XYZBounds();
+    gc.getBounds(bounds);
+    System.out.println("Bounds = "+bounds);
+    System.out.println("Point = "+gp);
+    final XYZSolid solid = XYZSolidFactory.makeXYZSolid(PlanetModel.WGS84, bounds.getMinimumX(), bounds.getMaximumX(), bounds.getMinimumY(), bounds.getMaximumY(), bounds.getMinimumZ(), bounds.getMaximumZ());
+    
+    assert gc.isWithin(gp)?solid.isWithin(gp):true;
+    
+  }
+  
 }