Commit Graph

135 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Nathan Gough 9da3b1ec01
NIFI-7912 - Added properties to configure DoSFilter timeout and whitelisted addresses
- Added nifi.web.request.ip.whitelist property to set DoSFilter.ipWhitelist
- Added nifi.web.request.timeout property to set DoSFilter.maxRequestMs with default of 60 seconds

This closes #4972

Signed-off-by: David Handermann <exceptionfactory@apache.org>
2021-04-07 07:40:03 -05:00
Joe Witt 88fab00e29
NIFI-7873 merging release branch to latest and updating to 1.14.0-SNAPSHOT 2021-02-15 12:09:32 -07:00
Joe Witt 4afb2ba743
NIFI-7873-RC4 prepare for next development iteration 2021-02-15 12:09:31 -07:00
Joe Witt 487280bee9
NIFI-7873-RC4 prepare release nifi-1.13.0-RC4 2021-02-15 12:09:30 -07:00
exceptionfactory 817f621d6f NIFI-8096 Deprecated ClientAuth references in SSLContextService
- Added SSLContextService.createContext() and refactored referencing components
- Removed references to ClientAuth from SslContextFactory methods

This closes #4737.

Signed-off-by: Mark Payne <markap14@hotmail.com>
2021-01-06 16:24:26 -05:00
exceptionfactory 28ca7478d6 NIFI-8019 Added TlsPlatform to provide runtime TLS protocol configuration
NIFI-8019 Renamed getDefaultProtocols() to getSupportedProtocols()

Signed-off-by: Nathan Gough <thenatog@gmail.com>

This closes #4673.
2020-12-14 19:34:58 -05:00
Mark Payne 3c9d8a7007
NIFI-7897: Refactoring to create a new nifi-framework-components module.
- Refactored nifi-stateless to make use of nifi-framework-components
- Removed requirement for nifi-framework-nar to be provided.
- Refactored stateless nifi into api, engine, nar, and bootstrap modules, with a parent 'bundle' module
- Creation of nifi-stateless-system-tests
- Added unit tests and logging
- Changed flow configuration to use properties file instead of json
- Allow for -p parameter to specify parameters on command line
- Moved implementations of Authorizer, NiFiUser, and UserGroupProviders to new module named nifi-framework-authorization-providers so that those that depend on nifi-framework-authorization don't have to bring in the providers. This way, we can have stateless not bring in those providers, as we otherwise get warnings on startup about the provider already being registered. Additionally, it avoids needing dependencies on spring-security-core
- Updated bin/nifi.sh script to run new stateless bootstrap
- Added Reporting Tasks to stateless.
- Download bundles as necessary on stateless nifi startup

NIFI-7897: Addressing review feedback

NIFI-7897: Fixed typos in README and also addressed issue that caused parameters with spaces not to be parsed properly

This closes #4669.

Signed-off-by: Bryan Bende <bbende@apache.org>
2020-11-24 11:37:45 -05:00
Andy LoPresto 9370571131
NIFI-7804 Split nifi-security-utils into sub-module for nifi-security… (#4533)
* NIFI-7804 Split nifi-security-utils into sub-module for nifi-security-utils-api (no external dependencies).
Separated interface and implementation of TlsConfiguration.
Reabsorbed nifi-security-xml-config into nifi-security-utils.

* NIFI-7804 Resolved failing unit test on Java 8.
Removed accidental module dependency.

* NIFI-7804 Resolved failing unit test.

* NIFI-7804 Removed legacy dependency.

* NIFI-7804 Marked nifi-security-utils-api as provided and overrode with compile scope in specific modules which are not children of nifi-standard-services-api-nar.
2020-09-17 12:52:22 -04:00
Joe Witt 8baa5c9940
NIFI-7692 updating for next dev release 1.13.0 2020-08-18 14:48:02 -07:00
Joe Witt fb57bcbc11
NIFI-7692-RC1 prepare for next development iteration 2020-08-13 09:20:39 -07:00
Joe Witt 303d6c59ba
NIFI-7692-RC1 prepare release nifi-1.12.0-RC1 2020-08-13 09:20:36 -07:00
Andy LoPresto dbee774c5b
NIFI-7304 Removed default value for nifi.web.max.content.size.
Added Bundle#toString() method.
Refactored implementation of filter addition logic.
Added logging.
Added unit tests to check for filter enablement.
Introduced content-length exception handling in StandardPublicPort.
Added filter bypass functionality for framework requests in ContentLengthFilter.
Updated property documentation in Admin Guide.
Renamed methods & added Javadoc to clarify purpose of filters in JettyServer.
Cleaned up conditional logic in StandardPublicPort.
Moved ContentLengthFilterTest to correct module.
Refactored unit tests for accuracy and clarity.
Fixed remaining merge conflict due to method renaming.

Signed-off-by: Joe Witt <joe.witt@gmail.com>
2020-07-14 10:42:00 -07:00
Andy LoPresto 0fa8776f4d
NIFI-7621 & NIFI-7614 Updated terminology throughout codebase and documentation.
Fixed unit test failures introduced from static imports during refactoring.

Signed-off-by: Joe Witt <joe.witt@gmail.com>
2020-07-14 10:39:28 -07:00
Mark Payne 57c7883f64
NIFI-7566: Avoid using Thread.sleep() to wait for Site-to-Site connection to be handled. Instead, use TimeUnit.timedWait and use Object.notifyAll when setting the beingServiced flag. This significantly reduces latency and improves throughput for small-batch site-to-site communications
This closes #4353.

Signed-off-by: Andy LoPresto <alopresto@apache.org>
2020-06-19 15:37:02 -07:00
Andy LoPresto 441781cec5
NIFI-7407 Replaced SSLContextFactory references to "TLS" with "TLSv1.2" (in shared constant).
Changed JettyServer default SSL initialization and updated unit test.
Removed SecurityStoreTypes (unused).
Added StringUtils inverted blank and empty checks.
Added TlsConfiguration container object.
Enhanced KeystoreType enum.
Added clean #createSSLContext() method to serve as base method for special cases/other method signatures.
Added utility methods in KeyStoreUtils.
Added generic TlsException for callers that cannot resolve TLS-specific exceptions.
Added utility methods for component object debugging.
Enforced TLS protocol version on cluster comms socket creation.
Added utility method for SSL server socket creation.
Refactored (Server)SocketConfigurationFactoryBean to store relevant NiFiProperties in TlsConfiguration instead of stateful SSLContextFactory (Cluster comms now enforce modern TLS protocol version).
Removed duplicate SSLContextFactory.
Switched duplicate SslContextFactory to wrap shared SSLContextFactory.
Refactored SslContextFactoryTest for clarity (will move any unique tests to nifi-security-utils class test).
Added further validation & boundary checking in uses of TlsConfiguration.
Provided SSLSocketFactory accessor in SslContextFactory.
Refactored OkHttpReplicationClient tuple method.
Refactored OcspCertificateValidator TLS logic.
Added utility method to apply TLS configs to OkHttpClientBuilder.
Removed references to duplicate SslContextFactory.
Removed unnecessary SslContextFactory.
Moved OkHttpClientUtils to nifi-web-util module.
Updated module dependencies.
Removed now empty nifi-security module.
Enforced TLS protocol selection on LB server socket.
Enforced TLS protocol selection on S2S server socket.
Applied specified TLS protocol versions to S2S socket creation.
Completed removal of legacy SSLContext creation methods from only remaining SslContextFactory.
Replaced references to creation methods throughout codebase.
Replaced references to unnecessary NiFiProperties file reads throughout tests.
Removed duplicate ClientAuth enum from SSLContextService and changed all references to SslContextFactory.ClientAuth.
Suppressed repeated TLS exceptions in cluster, S2S, and load balance socket listeners.
Cleaned up legacy code.
Added external timing check to timing test assertion.
Made RestrictedSSLContextService TLS protocol versions allowable values explicit.
Enabled TLSv1.3 on Java 11.
Added explanations of TLS protocol versions in StandardSSLContextService and StandardRestrictedSSLContextService.
Resolved additional Java 11 test failures for NiFi internal classes that don't support TLSv1.3. Filed NIFI-7468 as follow on task.

This closes #4263.

Signed-off-by: Nathan Gough <thenatog@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Mark Payne <markap14@hotmail.com>
2020-05-19 12:56:59 -07:00
Mark Payne afad982e91
NIFI-7200: Revert "NIFI-6530 - HTTP SiteToSite server returns 201 in case no data is available"
This reverts commit f01668e66a.

Signed-off-by: Joe Witt <joewitt@apache.org>
2020-03-10 14:32:43 -04:00
Joe Witt 3de77ebacc
NIFI-7021-RC3 prepare for next development iteration 2020-01-19 14:14:40 -05:00
Joe Witt 633408bce7
NIFI-7021-RC3 prepare release nifi-1.11.0-RC3 2020-01-19 14:14:38 -05:00
Mark Payne 5f4ce8f431
NIFI-6707: Addition of nifi-system-tests module. Updates to EmbeddedNiFi, NiFi and SystemBundle to properly support classloader isolation that is needed for creating system-level tests and isolating the classpath of the tests themselves from the NiFi classpath. Fixed bootstrap listener to ensure that it always closes socket before calling shutdown(). Failure to do so can result in RunNiFi sometimes timing out while waiting for a response from NiFi
NIFI-6707: Added System Test to verify behavior when services depend on one another

NIFI-6707: Ensure that when tearing down flow after test, we wait for all processors and controller services to complete stop/disable before attempting to delete them

NIFI-6707: Fixed bug in RemoteProcessGroupIT that caused the test to fail intermittently based on timing. Improved logging for Process Group, Standard Process Group

NIFI-6707: Updated to include java11 subdirectory under lib/

NIFI-6707: Rebased against master and changed dependencies from 1.10.0-SNAPSHOT to 1.11.0-SNAPSHOT

NIFI-6707: Updates to see if it will help travis build correctly

NIFI-6707: Commenting out java commands in bootstrap.conf files

This closes #3831.

Signed-off-by: Bryan Bende <bbende@apache.org>
2019-11-08 12:33:16 -05:00
Joe Witt f8c3d877cf
NIFI-6733 updating to next release version for master branch 2019-11-04 13:31:39 -05:00
Joe Witt 4119279c03
Merge branch 'NIFI-6733-RC3' 2019-11-04 13:24:29 -05:00
Joe Witt 363b751310
Revert "NIFI-6733 bumping master to 1.11.0-SNAPSHOT"
This reverts commit a7c56cfd9a.
2019-11-04 13:24:13 -05:00
Joe Witt a7c56cfd9a
NIFI-6733 bumping master to 1.11.0-SNAPSHOT 2019-11-04 07:54:17 -05:00
Mark Payne 0b3a60ae3e NIFI-6832: When receiving a 0-byte FlowFile via site-to-site, avoid writing to the FlowFile at all 2019-11-01 16:22:17 -04:00
Joe Witt 418179f5b2
NIFI-6733-RC3 prepare for next development iteration 2019-10-28 15:13:13 -07:00
Joe Witt b217ae20ad
NIFI-6733-RC3 prepare release nifi-1.10.0-RC3 2019-10-28 15:12:57 -07:00
Koji Kawamura 6541eac625
NIFI-6598 Storing peers into managed-state
- Fixed checkstyle errors.
- Added PeerPersistence interface.
- Expose RemoteProcessGroup state via REST API
- Made stateManager transient.

This closes #3677.

Signed-off-by: Bryan Bende <bbende@apache.org>
2019-10-01 09:56:10 -04:00
Koji Kawamura e659e3b606 NIFI-5952 Refactor RAW S2S from nio to socket 2019-09-13 10:30:04 -04:00
Arpad Boda f01668e66a
NIFI-6530 - HTTP SiteToSite server returns 201 in case no data is available
This closes #3647.

Signed-off-by: Koji Kawamura <ijokarumawak@apache.org>
2019-09-06 19:27:59 +09:00
Mark Payne 9ba280680f
NIFI-6569, NIFI-6570: Fixed bug that caused read timeouts not to occur with site-to-site. Fixed bug that caused site-to-site listener not to accept connections if there are no input/output ports on the root group - this used to be a valid check and was done to prevent spawning extra threads and doing extra work if no ports exist but now that we have site-to-site ports outside of the root group it's no longer a reasonable condition to check.
This closes #3658.

Signed-off-by: Koji Kawamura <ijokarumawak@apache.org>
2019-09-02 11:51:03 +09:00
Koji Kawamura e32689a602 NIFI-6436 Fix NPE at StandardPublicPort
Removing unnecessary ProcessGroup from PublicPort constructor.

This closes #3580.

Signed-off-by: Mark Payne <markap14@hotmail.com>
2019-08-19 15:33:26 -04:00
Mark Payne 4f50f30ad7
NIFI-6380: Introduced the notion of Parameters and Parameter Contexts to the code base.
- Added nifi-parameter module
- Added Parameter to nifi-api
- Added ParameterContext and ParameterLookup
- Updated EL to support Parameters
- Updated backend so that any property can make use of Parameters
- Added web endpoint for Parameter Contexts
- Updated Templates to make use of Parameter Contexts
- Updated Versioned Flows to make use of Parameter Contexts
- Updated Stateless NiFi to support Parameters and take Parameters as part of the configuration, not Variables.

NIFI-6380: Addressed review feedback and fixed bugs; added additional unit and integration tests to verify

NIFI-6380: Added Description to Parameter Context

NIFI-6380: Fixed checkstyle violations

NIFI-6380: Fixed bug that caused updating a Parameter Context to fail if the name is provided and unchanged

NIFI-6380: If parameter is being deleted, don't worry about its sensitivity flag. This addresses a bug where the deletion of a Sensitive Parameter would require that the Parameter be submitted with a value of null and a sensitivity flag of true; else it would provide an error indicating that the parameter can't be changed from sensitive to non-sensitive. Now, the sensitivity flag is ignored.

NIFI-6380: Fixed bug around unsetting Process Group's Parameter Context

NIFI-6380: Moved lastRefreshed timestamp from ParameterContextDTO to ParameterContextsEntity and renamed to currentTime to match the pattern of ControllerServicesEntity rather than FlowHistory. Added parameterContextId to ProcessGroupFlowDTO

NIFI-6380: Added additional integration tests around escaped parameter references

NIFI-6380: Additional tests and bug fix for referencing EL from within another EL Expression

NIFI-6380: Created ParameterEntity to house a 'canWrite' flag for parameters and updated ParameterContext to use it. Updated ParameterContextUpdateRequestDTO to include a Set<AffectedComponentEntity> indicating the components that are affected by the update

NIFI-6380: Addressed review feedback

NIFI-6380: Addressed additional review feedback, mostly around code cleanup

NIFI-6380: Bug fix

NIFI-6380: Addressed more review feedback; fixed a couple of minor bugs encountered when testing

NIFI-6380: Bug fix around Parameter escaping for properties that support Expression Language. Fixed inconcsistency in Authorization hierarchy between /parameter-contexts/1234 and /parameter-contexts  to ensure that the parent of /parameter-contexts is /controller, regardless of how we arrive at the /parameter-contexts resource

NIFI-6380: Fixed but around using ProcessContext#newPropertyValue(String) that previously resulted in causing the Parameters to be evaluated a second time, thereby ignoring escape characters. Updated Integration Test to verify behavior. Also fixed bug in LoadBalanceQueueIT as it was a one-liner and noticed it while running tests to verify other behavior

NIFI-6380: Ensure that if Processor or Controller Services references or de-references a Parameter that user making the change has READ policy on the Parameter Context

NIFI-6380: Verify permissions on Parameter Context when creating processor/controller service and when moving between groups, insantiating template, reverting/change flow version

NIFI-6380: Addressed problem that resulted from rebasing against master; fixed bug in showing the Affected Components for a particular Parameter Context Update

NIFI-6380: Fixed NPE that occurs when attempting to update controller-level Controller Service

NIFI-6380: Updated validation error text when referencing parameter from controller-level controller service or reporting task

NIFI-6380: Ensuring permissions for copy/paste when components reference parameters.

NIFI-6380: Do not require READ policy on Parameter Context in order to un-reference a parameter, only to reference one.

NIFI-6380: Restricted parameter names to match those in the Feature Proposal. Fixed bug that allowed copy & paste of a PG for which user does not have READ policy for a child/descendant PG's parameter context

This closes #3536
2019-08-02 10:45:39 -04:00
Jeff Storck 1d560e2b02 NIFI-6360 Updated Mockito to 2.28.2, PowerMock to 2.0.2
Fixed test failures in nifi-couchbase-processors, BinaryDocument matcher replaced with ByteArrayDocument
Fixed test failures in nifi-riemann-processors, anyInt() matcher replaced with anyLong() matcher, calling method passes a long, not int
Removed unnecessary method mocks from nifi-toolkit-tls tests, TlsCertificateAuthorityServiceHandlerTest and TlsCertificateSigningRequestPerformerTest, since those were flagged by Mockito as unnecessary (they're unused)
Removed explicit mockito dependency version in nifi-gcp-processors pom to inherit version from nifi's pom.xml
Updated ArgumentMatchers in Kafka 0.10, 0.11, 1.0, and 2.0 processor tests, since in Mockito 2.x, the "any" matchers no longer allow nulls
Updated ArgumentMatchers in nifi-jolt-transform-json-ui, since in Mockito 2.x, the "any" matchers no longer allow nulls
Removed unnecessary method mocks from MetricsReportingTaskTest
Updated TestStandardRemoteGroupPort to return Long instead of Integer for test flowfile.size() invocations
Updated AbstractCassandraProcessor to include keyspaceProperty.getValue() in null check
Updated SimpleProcessLogger and TestSimpleProcessLogger, vararg matching does not work the same in Java 8 and 11
Updated TestStandardProcessScheduler to allow null values during mock invocations, Mockito 2.x no longer allows nulls in those matchers
Updated TestPutHiveStreaming to allow null values during mock invocations, Mockito 2.x no longer allows nulls in those matchers
Updated FetchParquetTest to allow null values during mock invocations, Mockito 2.x no longer allows nulls in those matchers
Updated ControllerSearchServiceTest to allow null values during mock invocations, Mockito 2.x no longer allows nulls in those matchers
Removed usage of Whitebox from GetAzureEventHubTest due to Mockito 2.x, replaced with FieldUtils
Removed usage of Whitebox from StandardOidcIdentityProviderTest due to Mockito 2.x, replaced with FieldUtils
Updated apache-rat-plugin configuration in root POM to make use of useIdeaDefaultExcludes which makes the rat plugin exclude IntelliJ artifacts
Updated several modules to use mockito-core instead of mockito-all (discontinued in Mockito 2.x)
Updated nifi-site-to-site-reporting-task tests to be compatible with Mockito 2.x
Ignored TestPutJMS tests; the tests need to be refactored to work with Mockito 2.x, but the processor is deprecated.  Refactor may be done in a separate PR.
Adjusted several mock interaction iterations to 0 for TestPublishKafkaRecord_* tests.  Mockito 2.x flagged several interactions as unused and were adjusted to 0 interactions.
Updated PowerMock and Mockito dependencies to exclude transitive dependency on bytebuddy, added explicit dependency on bytebuddy 1.9.10 so that PowerMock and Mockito use the same version.  Bytebuddy 1.9.3 (used by PowerMock 2.0.2) did not allow for the mocking of final/private classes, bytebuddy 1.9.10 (used by Mockito 2.28.2) does.
Updated TestSiteToSiteProvenanceReportingTask use of InvocationOnMock.getArgument to use objects for the resulting object rather than primitives
Removed unnecessary stubs from evtx tests, Mockito 2.x defaults to strict mocks
Fixed classloader issue with tests in nifi-windows-event-log-processors module that use JNAJUnitRunner when Mockito mocked JNA classes (Kernel32)
Addressed Mockito-related deprecation warnings
Import cleanup

This closes #3533

Signed-off-by: Mike Thomsen <mikerthomsen@gmail.com>
2019-06-17 12:21:07 -04:00
Andy LoPresto e6c843f465
NIFI-6323 Changed URLs for repositories, project description, and mailing lists to use HTTPS.
NIFI-6323 Changed URLs for splunk.artifactoryonline.com to use HTTPS (certificate validity warning in browsers, but command-line connection using openssl s_client is successful).
NIFI-6323 Changed URLs for XMLNS schema locations to use HTTPS (the XMLNS and schema identifier remain http:// because they are not designed to be resolvable).
NIFI-6323 Fixed Maven XML schema descriptor URLs.

This closes #3497
2019-05-29 14:36:40 -04:00
Koji Kawamura 8a50cb10b2 NIFI-2933 Remote input/output ports at any PG
Specify remote access at port creation.
Incorporated comments, and finished refactoring.
Renamed RootGroupPort to PublicPort.
Fix error message for creating a connection from a child PG having only PublicPorts.
Enhanced ProcessGroup instances rendered in the parent ProcessGroup
Loosen Port move check, allow moving public port between PG.
Show 'Remote NiFi Instance' info on Connection dialogs
Make labels narrative.
'Within Remote Group'.
Fixed DTO (de)serialization.
Return null only if all values are null.

This closes #3351.

Signed-off-by: Mark Payne <markap14@hotmail.com>
2019-05-22 15:44:16 -04:00
Mark Payne 91b2283f49
NIFI-6183: Implemented base class for Framework-level integration tests that is responsible for instantiating the key components for integration tests, including FlowController, WriteAheadFlowFileRepository, WriteAheadProvenanceRepository, FileSystemRepository, FileSystemSwapManager, StandardFlowFileQueue, StandardProcessScheduler, etc. Implemented several integration tests to span different parts of the framework
This closes #3423.

Signed-off-by: Bryan Bende <bbende@apache.org>
2019-04-10 16:47:08 -04:00
Mark Payne 414bfc94fc NIFI-6068: Fixed unit test 2019-02-22 11:55:25 -05:00
Mark Payne e26bacf697 NIFI-6068, NIFI-6065: Updated StandardFunnel to avoid looping indefinitely and instead transfer no more than 10,000 FlowFiles before returning from onTrigger. Updated Local Ports to behavior in the same way. Updated Root Group Ports so that instead of blocking for up to 100 milliseconds for an incoming request, it blocks for up to 1 millisecond and if nothing is available yields for the 'bored yield duration'
Signed-off-by: Brandon Devries <devriesb@apache.org>

This closes #3328.
2019-02-22 10:12:20 -05:00
joewitt 0e204f3576
NIFI-6029-RC2 prepare for next development iteration 2019-02-16 21:50:35 -05:00
joewitt 45bb53d2aa
NIFI-6029-RC2 prepare release nifi-1.9.0-RC2 2019-02-16 21:50:15 -05:00
Jeff Storck c0182294ed NIFI-5720-RC3 prepare for next development iteration 2018-10-22 22:16:43 -04:00
Jeff Storck 98aabf2c50 NIFI-5720-RC3 prepare release nifi-1.8.0-RC3 2018-10-22 22:16:23 -04:00
Matt Gilman 02261311b3 NIFI-5737:
- Removing needClientAuth property since cluster comms now requires two way ssl. Jetty client auth settings are based on configured features.
- Removing dead code.
- Updating documentation.
- Removing references to needClientAuth property in all test resources.
- Removing overloaded util method with strict parameter.

This closes #3102.
2018-10-22 20:02:47 -04:00
Andy LoPresto f65286be83
NIFI-5622 Updated test resource keystores and truststores with SubjectAlternativeNames to be compliant with RFC 6125.
Refactored some test code to be clearer.
Renamed some resources to be consistent across modules.
Changed passwords to meet new minimum length requirements.

This closes #3018
2018-10-04 09:50:09 -04:00
Koji Kawamura e94f0757db
NIFI-4654: Support reporting RAS S2S lineage to Atlas
- Added 's2s.port.id' FlowFile attribute to track target remote Port id
- Use 's2s.port.id' to analyze RAW S2S provenance events
- This closes #2863
2018-07-10 11:44:00 -04:00
Andy LoPresto d42a1e8bf4
NIFI-5323-RC1 prepare for next development iteration 2018-06-19 20:02:21 -07:00
Andy LoPresto 99bcd1f88d
NIFI-5323-RC1 prepare release nifi-1.7.0-RC1 2018-06-19 20:02:01 -07:00
Matt Gilman 5cfa29e48f
NIFI-5135:
- Adding support for applying transforms to user identities and group names.

This closes #2673.

Signed-off-by: Bryan Bende <bbende@apache.org>
2018-05-07 11:17:26 -04:00
joewitt 59f625d3c2 Merge branch 'NIFI-4995-RC3' as part of NiFi 1.6.0 release process 2018-04-06 16:48:08 -07:00
Koji Kawamura 1913b1e2a8
NIFI-4932: Enable S2S work behind a Reverse Proxy
Adding S2S endpoint Reverse Proxy mapping capability.
Added license header to SVG files.
Incorporated review comments.
Use regex to check property key processing.
Catch AttributeExpressionLanguageParsingException.
This closes #2510
2018-04-03 15:40:28 -04:00