Builds on elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2403 to move all of sql's integration testing into
qa modules with different running server configurations. The
big advantage of this is that it allows us to test the cli and
jdbc with security present.
Creating a project that depends on both cli and jdbc and the
server has some prickly jar hell issues because cli and jdbc
package their dependencies in the jar. This works around it
in a few days:
1. Include only a single copy of the JDBC dependencies with
careful gradle work.
2. Do not include the CLI on the classpath at all and instead
run it externally.
I say "run it externally" rather than "fork it" because Elasticsearch
tests aren't allowed to fork other processes. This is forbidden
by seccomp on linux and seatbelt on osx and cannot be explicitly
requested like additional security manager settings. So instead
of forking the CLI process directly the tests interact with a test
fixture that isn't bound by Elasticsearch's rules and *can* fork
it.
This forking of the CLI has a nice side effect: it forces us to
make sure that things like security and connection strings other
than `localhost:9200` work. The old test could and did work around
missing features like that. The new tests cannot so I added the
ability to set the connection string. Configuring usernames and
passwords was also not supported but I did not add support for
that, only created the failing test and marked it as `@AwaitsFix`.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@560c6815e3
This commit adds back the ability to disable TLS on the transport layer and also disables TLS by
default to restore the 5.x behavior. The auto generation of key/cert and bundled CA certificate
have also been removed.
Relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2463
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@abc66ec67d
Instead of throwing and catching an exception for invalid
indices this returns *why* they are invalid in a convenient
object form that can be thrown as an exception when the index
is required or the entire index can be ignored when listing
indices.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@f45cbce647
This integrates SQL's metadata calls with security by creating
`SqlIndicesAction` and routing all of SQL's metadata calls through
it. Since it *does* know up from which indices it is working against
it can be an `IndicesRequest.Replaceable` and integrate with the
existing security infrastructure for filtering indices.
This request is implemented fairly similarly to the `GetIndexAction`
with the option to read from the master or from a local copy of
cluster state. Currently SQL forces it to run on the local copy
because the request doesn't properly support serialization. I'd
like to implement that in a followup.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@15f9512820
On Windows a named pipe server must call ConnectNamedPipe() before using
a named pipe. However, if the client has already connected then this
function returns a failure code, with detailed error code
ERROR_PIPE_CONNECTED. The server must check for this, as it means the
connection will work fine. The Java test that emulates what the C++
would do in production did not have this logic.
This was purely a test problem. The C++ code used in production already
does the right thing.
relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2359
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@e162887f28
The changes made for elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2369 showed that the ML security tests were seriously
weakened by the decision to grant many "minimal" privileges to all users
involved in the tests. A better solution is to override the auth header
such that a superuser runs setup actions and assertions that work by
querying raw documents in ways that an end user wouldn't. Then the ML
endpoints can be called with the privileges provided by the ML roles and
nothing else.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@4de42d9e54
Implementation details of ML endpoints should be performed using the
internal client, so that the end user only requires permissions for
the public ML endpoints and does not need to know how they are
implemented. This change fixes some instances where this rule was
not adhered to.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@01c8f5172c
* Add support for authz checks at on shard requests
* Add Rest Tests for authorization
* Bulk security - Only reject individual items, rather than a whole shard
* Sync with core change
* Grant "delete" priv in ML smoketest
This role had index and+bulk privileges but it also needs delete (in order to delete ML model-snapshots)
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@830e89e652
This shuffles all of SQL's QA tests into the `qa/sql` directory, moving
some shared resources into the new `qa:sql` project. It also rigs up
testing of the rest SQL interface in all the sql qa configurations:
without security, with security, and against multiple nodes.
I've had to make some modifications to how we handle the audit log
because it has gotten pretty slow. If these modifications turn out to
not be fast enough then I'll change the test to querying the log files
and drop the audit log index entirely but the index seems to be holding
out for now.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@ff3b5a74c1
This commit removes some extraneous trailing newlines from
keystore.bash, the packaging test cases for the interaction between
installing X-Pack and the keystore.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@86250ecfbc
Scrolling was only implemented for the `SqlAction` (not jdbc or cli)
and it was implemented by keeping request state on the server. On
principle we try to avoid adding extra state to elasticsearch where
possible because it creates extra points of failure and tends to
have lots of hidden complexity.
This replaces the state on the server with serializing state to the
client. This looks to the user like a "next_page" key with fairly
opaque content. It actually consists of an identifier for the *kind*
of scroll, the scroll id, and a base64 string containing the field
extractors.
Right now this only implements scrolling for `SqlAction`. The plan
is to reuse the same implementation for jdbc and cli in a followup.
This also doesn't implement all of the required serialization.
Specifically it doesn't implement serialization of
`ProcessingHitExtractor` because I haven't implemented serialization
for *any* `ColumnProcessors`.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@a8567bc5ec
`authc.token.enabled` is true unless `http.ssl.enabled` is `false` and `http.enabled` is `true`.
* TokenService default enabled if HTTP_ENABLED == false
* Fixed tests that need TokenService explicitly enabled
* [DOC] Default value for `xpack.security.authc.token.enabled`
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@bd154d16eb
As there are two indices to upgrade for watcher, it makes a lot of sense
to also have two upgrade checks.
There is one upgrader for the watches index, which deletes
old templates, adds the new one before and then does the reindexing.
Same for the triggered watches index.
This also means, that there will be two entries popping up in the kibana
UI.
Note: Each upgrade check checks if the other index (for the .watches
upgrade check the triggered watches index and vice versa) is already
upgraded and only if that is true, watcher is restarted.
relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2238
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@2c92040ed6
Today we require a pre-shared key to use the token service. Beside the
additional setup step it doesn't allow for key-rotation which is a major downside.
This change adds a TokenService private ClusterState.Custom that is used to distribute
the keys used to encrypt tokens. It also has the infrastructur to add automatic key
rotation which is not in use yet but included here to illustrate how it can work down
the road.
This is considered a prototype and requires additioanl integration testing. Yet, it's fully
BWC with a rolling / full cluster restart from a previous version (also from 5.6 to 6.x)
since if the password is set it will just use it instead of generating a new one.
Once we implement the automatic key rotation via the clusterstate we need to ensure that we are
fully upgraded before we do that.
Also note that the ClusterState.Custom is fully transient and will never be serialized to disk.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@1ae22f5d41
Today we require the `bootstrap.password` to be present in the keystore in order to
bootstrap xpack. With the addition of `keystore.seed` we have a randomly generated password
per node to do the bootstrapping. This will improve the initial user experience significantly
since the user doesn't need to create a keystore and add a password, they keystore is created
automatically unless already present and is always created with this random seed.
Relates to elastic/elasticsearch#26253
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@5a984b4fd8
Adapts audit logging to actions that delay getting index access control until the action is started. The audit log will contain an entry for the action itself starting without any associated indices because the indices are not yet known. The audit log will also contain an entry for every time the action resolved security for a set of indices. Since sql resolves indices one at a time it will contain an entry per index.
All of this customization is entirely in the security code. The only SQL change in this PR is to add audit logging support to the integration test.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@539bb3c2a8
The rest test waited for the watch to run in the background, but there
were no guarantees that this really happened. Also it waited for five
seconds, instead of just executing the watch manually.
relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2255
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@56765a649e
These tests have repeating but not reproducible failures,
where the stash is filled with a second PUT operation and the
watcher stats response does not match. Setting the log to trace
should shed some light on this.
As the smoke tests are only four tests this will not lead to a
log explosion.
Relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1513, elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1874
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@5832dc7990
Adds a test that shows *how* SQL fails to address an index with two types
to the full cluster restart tests. Because we're writing this code
against 7.0 don't actually execute the test, but we will execute it when
we merge to 6.x and it *should* work.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@b536e9a142
This adds support for field level security to SQL by creating a new type of flow for securing requests that look like sql requests. `AuthorizationService` verifies that the user can execute the request but doesn't check the indices in the request because they are not yet ready. Instead, it adds a `BiFunction` to the context that can be used to check permissions for an index while servicing the request. This allows requests to cooperatively secure themselves. SQL does this by implementing filtering on top of its `Catalog` abstraction and backing that filtering with security's filters. This minimizes the touch points between security and SQL.
Stuff I'd like to do in followups:
What doesn't work at all still:
1. `SHOW TABLES` is still totally unsecured
2. `DESCRIBE TABLE` is still totally unsecured
3. JDBC's metadata APIs are still totally unsecured
What kind of works but not well:
1. The audit trail doesn't show the index being authorized for SQL.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@86f88ba2f5
This commit re-enables the OpenLDAP tests that were previously running against a one-off instance
in AWS but now run against a vagrant fixture. There were some IntegTests that would run against the
OpenLDAP instance randomly but with this change they no longer run against OpenLDAP. This is ok as
the functionality that is tested by these has coverage elsewhere.
relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1823
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@ac9bc82297
SQL relies on being able to fetch information about fields from
the cluster state and it'd be disasterous if that information
wasn't available. This should catch that.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@1a62747332
Running the sql rest action test inside the server caused a dependency
loop which was failing the build.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@43283671d8
Replacing integration tests with rest tests and unit tests, thus removing integration tests that require start of a new cluster. Removing unused testing methods
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@265966d80c
Some standalone tests set the max script compilation limit. However,
this setting is now set in the main cluster setup in core so it is no
longer needed here. This commit removes these obviated settings in
standalone tests.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@089328c8d7
The full cluster restart tests are currently geared towards the 5.6 -> 6.0 upgrade and have some
issues when the versions are changed to 6.x -> 7.0. One issue is a real code issue in that the
security code always expects the mappings to have the same version as the version of the node, but
we no longer update the mappings on the security index during a rolling upgrade. We know look at
the index format to determine if the index is up to date.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@14c1c72ff6
The command line flag --path.conf was removed yet this test was still
using it. This commit replaces the usage of this flag in this test with
the new mechanism.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@c37050894c
Add some basic security testing/integration.
The good news:
1. Basic security now works. Users without access to an index can't run sql queries against it. Without this change they could.
2. Document level security works! At least so far as I can tell.
The work left to do:
1. Field level security doesn't work properly. I mean, it kind of works in that the field's values don't leak but it just looks like they all have null values.
2. We will need to test scrolling.
3. I've only added tests for the rest sql action. I'll need to add tests for jdbc and the CLI as well.
4. I've only added tests for `SELECT` and have ignored stuff like `DESCRIBE` and `SHOW TABLES`.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@b9909bbda0
This commit improves the error message in 6x if the security index has
not been upgraded, and warns the user that the native realm will not be
functional until the upgrade API is run.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@710b7634b4
the upgrade API is lacking some functionality in a special case,
where triggered_watches exists, but .watches does not. This
deletes the triggered watches index manually until we integrated
this properly in the upgrade API to fix the tests
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@e9d1b0d35d
This commit adds the upgrade API functionality and script for security.
It also enables previously muted tests that would fail due to the lack
of security upgrade features in testing cluster restarts and old
security index backward compatibility.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@4abe9f1263
The current tests were only able to finish successfully, if the earlier
tests were run as well, you could not run the restart test in isolation.
This commit ensures an upgrade is executed if needed.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@616ebbd6eb
Otherwise we might run into race conditions that prevent a useful
start up again.
Those tests can be massively improved (no need to run against the real
master node), once the watcher BWC compatible stats are in.
relates elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#2004
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@52ca77809c
This is related to elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1217. This commit requires that the elastic password
be bootstrapped for the user to be authenticated. As a result it removes
the special "setup" mode that allowed the user to be authenticated from
localhost.
Additionally, this commit updates the tests to work with this
functionality.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@d0d5d697a7
When a user asks for upgrade information for all indices and there are no indices in the cluster, upgrade assistance should just return an empty response indicating that no indices require upgrade or reindexing. This commit also reverts the temporary fix in WatchBackwardsCompatibilityIT tests that was added as a workaround for this issue.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@2ea9707867
This allows for messages to be returned, and distinguishes between 4 different results:
- I have authenticated the user
- I don't know how to authenticate that user. Try another realm.
- I tried to authenticate the user, but failed. Try another realm.
- I tried to authenticate the user, but failed. Fail the authentication attempt.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@f796949cfb
When there are data or master nodes in the cluster, that are older
than ES 6.0 alpha3, then watcher will only start on the master node.
Changed all transport actions to be master node actions, as there is
already a method to decide to run locally, which we can piggyback on.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@65cecb6d69
Requests that execute a stored script will no longer be allowed to specify the lang of the script. This information is stored in the cluster state making only an id necessary to execute against. Putting a stored script will still require a lang.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@926a7b2d86
This test creates watches in old versions of elasticsearch, upgrades them after upgrading cluster to the latest version and then tests that they were upgraded correctly.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@b9d45eb2a5
This commit is related to elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1896. Currently setup mode means that the
password must be set post 6.0 for using x-pack. This interferes with
upgrade tests as setting the password fails without a properly
upgraded security index.
This commit loosens two aspects of the security.
1. The old default password will be accept in setup mode (requests
from localhost).
2. All request types can be submitted in setup mode.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@8a2a577038
This commit removes the system key from master and changes watcher to use a secure setting instead
for the encryption key.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@5ac95c60ef
This is related to elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch#1217. This PR removes the default password of
"changeme" from the reserved users.
This PR adds special behavior for authenticating the reserved users. No
ReservedRealm user can be authenticated until its password is set. The
one exception to this is the elastic user. The elastic user can be
authenticated with an empty password if the action is a rest request
originating from localhost. In this scenario where an elastic user is
authenticated with a default password, it will have metadata indicating
that it is in setup mode. An elastic user in setup mode is only
authorized to execute a change password request.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@e1e101a237
The .security index used several different types to differentiate the
documents added to the index (users, reserved-users, roles, etc). Since
types are deprecated in 6.x, this commit changes the .security index
access layer to only use a single type and have all documents in the
index be of that single type. To differentiate documents that may have
the same id (e.g. the same user name and role name), the appropriate
type of the document is prepended to the id. For example, a user named
"jdoe" will now have the document id "user-jdoe".
This commit also ensures that any native realm security index operations
that lead to auto creation of the security index first go through the process
of creating the internal security index (.security-v6) and creating the alias
.security to point to the internal index.
Lastly, anytime the security index is accessed without having been
upgraded, an exception is thrown notifying the user to use the
upgrade API to upgrade the security index.
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@cc0a474aed
This commit adds new settings for the ssl keystore (not the ES keystore)
passphrase settings. New setting names are used, instead of trying to
support the existing names in both yml and the ES keystore, so that
there does not need to be complicated logic between the two. Note that
the old settings remain the only way to set the ssl passphrases for the
transport client, but the Settings object for transport clients are
created in memory by users, so they are already as "secure" as having a
loaded ES keystore. Also note that in the long term future (6.x
timeframe?) these settings should be deprecated and the keys/certs
themselves should be moved into the ES keystore, so there will be no
need for separate keystores/passphrases.
relates elastic/elasticsearch#22475
Original commit: elastic/x-pack-elasticsearch@be5275fa3d
Nik Everett
Tanguy Leroux
Tim Brooks
Jay Modi
Igor Motov
David Kyle
David Roberts
Tim Vernum
Jason Tedor
Michael Basnight
Alexander Reelsen
Albert Zaharovits
Simon Willnauer
Ryan Ernst
Ali Beyad
jaymode
Jack Conradson
Dimitrios Athanasiou