Currently, DOM node removal called `removeChild` on the saved parent
node when destroying a component. However, this will fail if the
component has been manually moved in the DOM. This change makes the
removal always use the node's real `parentNode` and ignore the provided
`parent`.
PR Close#28455
Ivy allows Components to extend Directives (but not the other way around) and as a result we may have Component and Directive annotations present at the same time. The logic that resolves annotations to pick the necessary one didn't take this into account and as a result Components were recognized as Directives (and vice versa) in case of inheritance. This change updates the resolution logic by picking known annotation that is the nearest one (in inheritance tree) and compares it with expected type. That should help avoid mis-classification of Components/Directives during resolution.
PR Close#28439
The logic to create additional files needed for Bazel are currently
hosted in `ng new`. Such files include the main.*.ts files needed
for AOT and a different angular.json to use Bazel builder, among others.
This commit refactors the logic into `ng add` so that it can be used to
perform the same modifications in an existing project. Users could do so
by running `ng add @angular/bazel`.
With this change, `ng new` effectively becomes an orchestrator that runs
the original `ng new` followed by `ng add @angular/bazel`.
PR Close#28436
Note that this fixes `compiler-cli` tests within `compiler-cli/test`,
but there seem to be remaining `ngcc` tests within `compiler-cli/src`
which aren't working on Windows. This is out-of-scope for this commit.
PR Close#28352
Currently the "ngtsc` testing helpers resolve the `fake_core` NPM
package using the `TEST_SRCDIR` variable. This is problematic on Windows
where Bazel runfiles are not symlinked into the runfiles directory.
In order to properly resolve the NPM Bazel tree artifact, we use the
`resolveTreeNpmArtifact` runfile helper that properly resolves the artifact
properly on all platforms.
PR Close#28352
In order to support running "compiler-cli" tests that use the "test_support.ts"
utilities on Windows with Bazel, we need to imporve the logic that resolves NPM
packages and symlinks them into a temporary directory.
A more Bazel idiomatic and windows compatible way of resolving Bazel runfiles
is to use the "RUNFILES_MANIFEST" if present. This ensures that the NPM
packages can be also symlinked on Windows, and tests can execute properly
on Windows. Read more about why this is needed here:
* https://github.com/bazelbuild/bazel/issues/3726#issue-257062364
PR Close#28352
Since we recently removed the `test.sh` script, and now run
all tests with Bazel, we can remove the unused logic that makes
compiler-cli tests pass in non-Bazel.
This cleans up the tests, and also makes it easier to write tests
without worrying about two ways of the Angular package output
(Bazel `ng_package` rules vs. old `build.sh` logic of building)
PR Close#28352
Since we recently removed the `test.sh` script, and now run all
tests with Bazel, we can remove the unused logic that makes language-service
tests pass in non-Bazel.
This cleans up the tests, and also makes it easier to write tests
without worrying about two ways of the Angular package output
(Bazel `ng_package` rules vs. old `build.sh` logic of building)
PR Close#28352
Note that this allows Angular to depend on the entirety of the ES2015 API, not just our restricted subset.
This change is needed because our copy of the subset was out-of-date, and prevents us using ES2015 target in dev mode.
This is a subset of https://github.com/angular/angular/pull/27738
PR Close#28134
Improve the stacktrace for `R3Injector` errors by adding the source component (or module) that tried to inject the missing provider, as well as the name of the injector which triggered the error (`R3Injector`).
e.g.:
```
R3InjectorError(SomeModule)[car -> SportsCar]:
NullInjectorError: No provider for SportsCar!
```
FW-807 #resolve
FW-875 #resolve
PR Close#28207
createInjector() is an Ivy-only API that should not have
been exported as part of the public API. This commit removes
the export. It will be re-exported when Ivy is released.
PR Close#28509
Currently we depend on the "rules_webtesting" version that is
installed by "rules_typescript//:package.bzl". This version of
the webtesting rules comes with a very old version of Chromium
and the `chromedriver` that does not support capturing console
errors properly (with stack traces). Since we have a few e2e
tests that depend on console output (e.g. playground/src/source-map),
we need to make sure that these tests can pass upon Bazel
migration.
PR Close#28490
Fixes Ivy not passing thrown errors along to the `ErrorHandler`.
**Note:** the failing test had to be reworked a little bit, because it has some assertions that depend on an error context being logged, however Ivy doesn't keep track of the error context.
This PR resolves FW-840.
PR Close#28447
In Ivy, we support a new manual mode that allows for stricter control
over change detection in OnPush components. Specifically, in this mode,
events do not automatically mark OnPush views as dirty. Only changed
inputs and manual calls to `markDirty()` actually mark a view dirty.
However, this mode cannot be the default for OnPush components if we
want to be backwards compatible with View Engine. This commit re-adds
the legacy logic for OnPush components where events always mark views
dirty and makes it the default behavior.
Note: It is still TODO to add a public API for manual change detection.
PR Close#28474
Due to the fact that the test in 'ng_module_integration_spec.ts' relied on internal VE data structures (the '_def' field) to verify the state and the structure has changed in Ivy, this commit adds an Ivy version of the same test.
PR Close#28477
This commit fixes a bug in the Bazel builder in which the path to Bazel
executable is constructed using the project path. For non-default
project, the node_modules directory is actually one level above the
project path.
This PR fixes the bug by resolving node_modules with require.resolve().
It requires @bazel/bazel v0.22.1 because previous versions do not have
index.js or main field in package.json and would cause node module
resolution to fail.
This has been tested with both bazel and ibazel.
PR Close#28478
Previously, attempting to destroy a view with listeners more than once
throws an error during event listener cleanup. This happens because
`cleanup` field on the `TView` has already been cleared out by the time
the second destruction runs.
The `destroyed` flag on LView was previously being set in the `destroyLView` function,
but this flag was never _checked_ anywhere in the codebase. This commit
moves _setting_ this flag to the `cleanupView` function, just before
destroy hooks are called. This is necessary because the destroy hooks
can contain arbitrary user code, such as (surprise!) attempting to
destroy the view (again). We also add a check to `destroyLView` to skip
already-destroyed views. This prevents the cleanup code path from running twice.
PR Close#28413
This lets us run ngtsc under the tsc_wrapped custom compiler (Used in Bazel)
It also allows others to simply wire ngtsc into an existing typescript compilation binary
PR Close#28435
In View Engine, we supported @Input and @ContentChild annotations
on the same property. This feature was somewhat brittle because
it would only work for static queries, so it would break if a
content child was passed in wrapped in an *ngIf. Due to the
inconsistent behavior and low usage both internally and externally,
we will likely be deprecating it in the next version, and it does
not make sense to perpetuate it in Ivy.
This commit ensures that we now throw in Ivy if we encounter the
two annotations on the same property.
PR Close#28415
Prior to this change we didn't verify types passed to bootstrap as a part of NgModule semantics verification. Now we check whether all types passed to bootstrap are actually Components.
PR Close#28386
This commit updates the token used in fakeAsync test to the one available in both VE and R3 TestBeds. The goal of the test is to verify that fakeAsync works with inject function, so the actual token that is used for a test is irrelevant in that case. The logic to retrieve tokens from compiler injector (that the comment in "fixmeIvy" refers to) was implemented in PR #28196.
PR Close#28383
Prior to this change, generation of host bindings and host styles was guarded by the "if" statement, which always returned true. Enforcing more strict check for bindings length broke some tests, since host styling instructions generation were inside the same "if" block. This update decouples bindings instruction generation from styling instructions, which makes it less error prone.
PR Close#28379
Prior to this change we may encounter some errors (like pipes being used where they should not be used) while compiling Host Bindings and Listeners. With this update we move validation logic to the analyze phase and throw an error if something is wrong. This also aligns error messages between Ivy and VE.
PR Close#28356
Adds the information that the templateUrl and styleUrls options supports only relative Urls.
Adds more information about relative paths and absolute URLs in project metadata.
PR Close#27962
The TypeTranslatorVisitor visitor returned strings because before it wasn't possible to transform declaration files directly through the TypeScript custom transformer API.
Now that's possible though, so it should return nodes instead.
PR Close#28342
The current DtsFileTransformer works by intercepting file writes and editing the source string directly.
This PR refactors it as a afterDeclaration transform in order to fit better in the TypeScript API.
This is part of a greater effort of converting ngtsc to be usable as a TS transform plugin.
PR Close#28342
When testing whether `value` is an object, use the ideal sequence of
strictly not equal to `null` followed by `typeof value === 'object'`
consistently. Specifically there's no point in using double equal with
`null` since `undefined` is ruled out by the `typeof` check.
Also avoid the unnecessary ToBoolean check on `value.ngOnDestroy` in
`hasOnDestroy()`, since the `typeof value.ngOnDestroy === 'function'`
will only let closures pass and all closures are truish (with the
notable exception of `document.all`, but that shouldn't be relevant
for the `ngOnDestroy` hook).
PR Close#28400
Previously, these components were not added to the view tree for the
(fake) root view in which they were bootstrapped. Without this,
root view destruction does not work as expected since the root view's
children are not present to be also destroyed.
PR Close#28409
This lets us run ngtsc under the tsc_wrapped custom compiler (Used in Bazel)
It also allows others to simply wire ngtsc into an existing typescript compilation binary
PR Close#28431
This commit updates test that was added after Content Queries inheritance fix (that renames some instructions) was merged into master. The test used previous version of instructions, thus causing failures after merging Content Queries inheritance fix.
PR Close#28414
This lets us run ngtsc under the tsc_wrapped custom compiler (Used in Bazel)
It also allows others to simply wire ngtsc into an existing typescript compilation binary
PR Close#27806
* Improves the `compiler-cli/integrationtest` codegen output test slightly by using a more clear test description and by adding an assertion that ensures that decorators are downleveled.
PR Close#28191
* Fixes that the test logic for `ngtools` in the offline compiler test is no longer working due to being unmaintained for a long time
* Makes the path comparison logic platform agnostic, so that the tests can be also executed on Windows
PR Close#28191
Prior to this change contentQueriesRefresh functions that represent refresh logic for @ContentQuery list were not composable, which caused problems in case one Directive inherits another one and both of them contain Content Queries. Due to the fact that we used indices to reference queries in refresh function, results were placed into wrong Queries. In order to avoid that we no longer use indices to reference queries and instead maintain current content query index while iterating through them. This allows us to compose contentQueriesRefresh functions and make inheritance feature work with Content Queries.
PR Close#28324
Currently `compileNgModule` generates an empty array for optional fields that are omitted from an `NgModule` declaration (e.g. `bootstrap`, `exports`). This isn't necessary, because `defineNgModule` has some code to default these fields to empty arrays at runtime if they aren't defined. The following changes will only output code if there are values for the particular field.
PR Close#28387
* No longer builds the example e2e tests using "tsc". The examples are now built with Bazel and can therefore be built with Ivy by using the `--define=compile=aot` switch.
* No longer runs the example e2e tests using the protractor CLI. example e2e tests are executed with the Bazel protractor rule and can therefore run incrementally.
NOTE: Unit tests found within the examples are still running within the legacy jobs.
PR Close#28402
In some cases, calling getSourceFile() on a node from within a TS
transform can return undefined (against the signature of the method).
In these cases, getting the original node first will work.
PR Close#28412
By its nature, Ivy alters the import graph of a TS program, adding imports
where template dependencies exist. For example, if ComponentA uses PipeB
in its template, Ivy will insert an import of PipeB into the file in which
ComponentA is declared.
Any insertion of an import into a program has the potential to introduce a
cycle into the import graph. If for some reason the file in which PipeB is
declared imports the file in which ComponentA is declared (maybe it makes
use of a service or utility function that happens to be in the same file as
ComponentA) then this could create an import cycle. This turns out to
happen quite regularly in larger Angular codebases.
TypeScript and the Ivy runtime have no issues with such cycles. However,
other tools are not so accepting. In particular the Closure Compiler is
very anti-cycle.
To mitigate this problem, it's necessary to detect when the insertion of
an import would create a cycle. ngtsc can then use a different strategy,
known as "remote scoping", instead of directly writing a reference from
one component to another. Under remote scoping, a function
'setComponentScope' is called after the declaration of the component's
module, which does not require the addition of new imports.
FW-647 #resolve
PR Close#28169
This commit implements a cycle detector which looks at the import graph of
TypeScript programs and can determine whether the addition of an edge is
sufficient to create a cycle. As part of the implementation, module name
to source file resolution is implemented via a ModuleResolver, using TS
APIs.
PR Close#28169
Builder for `@angular/bazel` schematics should not expect bazel/ibazel
to be on the PATH. It should instead invoke the local executable
installed by yarn/npm.
PR Close#28303
Users should be able to add Bazel workspace to an existing project.
The current approach assumes that the schematics is working on the same
tree as that of ng-new, which includes the top-level directory. Instead,
the schematic should work on the tree rooted at `appRoot` to enable
Bazel files to be added to existing project.
This change uses the newly implemented ScopedTree
a0ac4b0e3d
to achieve this.
NOTE: The version of `@angular-devkit/schematics` that is installed is
used to run the `@angular/bazel` schematic. Even if a different version
is used in the schematic itself, it has no effect.
Therefore, the *latest* Angular CLI should be used to generate the
files. As of this commit, the latest version is @angular/cli@7.3.0-rc.0
PR Close#28349
TestBed.compileComponents has always been an async API. However,
ViewEngine tolerated using this API in a synchronous manner if the
components declared in the testing module did not have any async
resources (templateUrl, styleUrls). This change makes the ivy TestBed
mirror this tolerance by configuring such components synchronously.
Ref: FW-992
PR Close#28350
ngcc's reflection host needs to be able to determine all members of a
class, which it does by using the `ts.Symbol` from TypeScript's
TypeChecker. Such Symbol however may represent multiple class members
in the case of accessors; an equally named getter/setter accessor pair
is combined into a single `ts.Symbol`.
This commit introduces logic to recognize such accessors in order for
both the getter and setter to be considered as class member, similar to
ngtsc's behavior when operating on original TypeScript code.
One difference wrt the TypeScript host is that ngcc cannot see to which
accessor originally had any decorators applied to them, as decorators
are applied to the property descriptor in general, not a specific accessor.
If an accessor has both a setter and getter, any decorators are only
attached to the setter member.
PR Close#28357
Prior to this change, accessor functions for getters and setters would
not be considered as class member, as their declaration is vastly
different from ES2015 syntax.
With this change, the ES5 reflection host has learned to recognize the
downleveled syntax for accessors, allowing for them to be considered as
class member once again.
Fixes#28226
PR Close#28357
yarn install was disabled in ng-new for Bazel schematics because
Bazel manages its own node_modules dependencies and therefore
there is no need to install dependencies twice.
However, the first yarn install is needed for `ng` commands to work,
most notably `ng build`.
This commit restores the original behavior.
PR Close#28381
This commit unifies handling of the "check no changes" mode between
ngIvy and the view engine. More specifically:
- check no changes can be invoked before change detection in ivy;
- `undefined` values are considered equal `NO_CHANGES` for the "check no changes"
mode purposes.
Chanes in this commit enables several tests that were previously running only in ivy
or only in the view engine.
PR Close#28366
Prior to this change the postprocess step relied on the order of placeholders combined in one group (e.g. [�#1�|�*1:1�]). The order is not guaranteed in case we have nested templates (since we use BFS to process templates) and some tags are represented using same placeholders. This change performs postprocessing more accurate by keeping track of currently active template and searching for matching placeholder.
PR Close#28209
Due to the fast moving nature of the Ivy codebase, the timing isn't
right to make changes to how errors and reported and handled during the
runtime.
Once ivy is stable this test should be revisted because that stage there
will be a better and more robust understanding of how ivy should recover
from runtime errors.
Jira Issue: FW-952
PR Close#28212
DebugElement.properties should contain a map of element
property names to element property values, with entries
for both normal property bindings and host bindings.
This commit adds support for property bindings in
DebugElement.properties (including interpolations).
PR Close#28355
DebugElement.properties should contain a map of element
property names to element property values, with entries
for both normal property bindings and host bindings.
Many Angular core tests depend on this map being present.
This commit adds support for host property bindings in
DebugElement.properties, which fixes the Angular core tests.
There is still work to be done for normal property bindings.
PR Close#28355
The value here is unimportant on initialization since it's not looked at until the second navigation. However, sometimes in testing the `Location` service is mocked out, or the Router constructor manually called. Assuming `Location` exists in the constructor leads to test failures in `google3` therefore we initialize to a value that will not cause errors.
PR Close#28376
animate functions now contain style functions instead of plain objects
e.g. animate(1s, { background: black }))
to animate(1s, style({ background: black }))
PR Close#28305
Previous to this change, we were storing view queries at the
wrong index. This is because we were passing a raw index to the
store() instruction instead of an adjusted index (i.e. an
index that does not include the HEADER_OFFSET). We had an
additional issue where TView.blueprint was not backfilled
when TView.data was backfilled, so new component instances
created from the blueprint would end up having a shorter LView.
Both of these problems together led to the Material demo app
failing with Ivy. This commit fixes those discrepancies.
PR Close#28327
Previously, bootstrapping a component with render3 would create a chained injector with the test bed ngModule instead of the ngModule that the component belongs to.
Now when a component belongs to an ngModule, we use that for the chained injector, ensuring the correct injection of any providers that this ngModule contains.
FW-776 #resolve
PR Close#28183
Fixes components with native content projection (using `<content>` or `<slot>`) not working under Ivy.
The issue comes from the fact that when creating elements inside a component, we sometimes don't append the element immediately, but we leave it to projection to move it into its final destination. This ends up breaking the native projection, because the slots have to be in place from the beginning. The following changes switch to appending the element immediately when inside a component with Shadow DOM encapsulation.
This PR resolves FW-841.
PR Close#28261
There are cases where we should check an element injector but don't go
into the associated module injector if a token is not found. In both the
view engine and ngIvy this is acheived by passing the
`NOT_FOUND_CHECK_ONLY_ELEMENT_INJECTOR` as the `notFoundValue`.
Before this fix the view engine and ngIvy were using different objects to
represent `NOT_FOUND_CHECK_ONLY_ELEMENT_INJECTOR`. This was causing problems
as ngUpgrade is using `NOT_FOUND_CHECK_ONLY_ELEMENT_INJECTOR` const in its
`NgAdapterInjector` to prevent searching of module injectors.
This commit makes sure that ngIvy is using the same object to represent
`NOT_FOUND_CHECK_ONLY_ELEMENT_INJECTOR` as the view engine.
PR Close#28313
Prior to this change `viewQuery` functions that represent @ViewQuery list were not composable, which caused problems in case one Component/Directive inherits another one and both of them contain View Queries. Due to the fact that we used indices to reference queries, resulting query set was corrupted (child component queries were overridden by super class ones). In order to avoid that we no longer use indices assigned at compile time and instead maintain current view query index while iterating through them. This allows us to compose `viewQuery` functions and make inheritance feature work with View Queries.
PR Close#28309
- Wraps the NgOnChangesFeature in a factory such that no side effects occur in the module root
- Adds comments to ngInherit property on feature definition interface to help guide others not to make the same mistake
- Updates compiler to generate the feature properly after the change to it being a factory
- Updates appropriate tests
PR Close#28187
This changes restores parity between VE TestBed and R3TestBed logic related to retrieving tokens using TestBed.get function. Now R3TestBed also tries to retrieve tokens from Compiler Injector.
PR Close#28196
Before this commit we were creating a "fake" TNode for each and every
projectable node passed during dynamic component creation. This approach
had several problems:
- the existing TView structure had to be mutated to accomodate new TNodes and
it was very easy to "corrupt" TView / TNode data structures;
- TNodes are not really needed to fully support projectable nodes so we were
creating objects and updating existing data structures for nothing.
This commit changes the approach so we don't create "fake" TNodes for projectable
nodes but instead we process projectable nodes directly in the projection instruction.
As a result we've got less code, less object allocation and - as a bonus - we fix few
bugs where TView / TNode data structures were corrupted when using projectable nodes.
PR Close#28275
Fixes the template generation function generating an incorrect tag name when the element has a namespace (e.g. `:svg:circle` gets generated rather than `circle`).
PR Close#28298
With #27680, a bug was fixed where multiple redirects using `eager` URL update could cause navigation to fail. However, that fix introduced a problem where with `skipLocationChange` enabled, the URL tree rendered was not properly stored for reference. This specifically caused an issue with named router outlets and subsequent navigations not being recognized.
This PR stores the correct `UrlTree` for reference with later navigations. It fixes the regression introdued with #27680.
Fixes#28200
PR Close#28300
Fixes Ivy not applying properties that are set in camelCase, because it goes through the `CSSStyleDeclaration` API via `setProperty` and `removeProperty` which requires for [the values to be in dash-case](https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/CSSStyleDeclaration/setProperty).
**Note:** I opted to let the browser normalize the value, rather than convert it to dash-case during compile time, because there are some special cases like browser-prefixed properties where we might not normalize it in-line with the browser.
This PR fixes FW-579.
PR Close#28276
This commit uses the NgModuleRouteAnalyzer introduced previously to
implement listLazyRoutes() for NgtscProgram. Currently this implementation
is limited to listing routes globally and cannot list routes for a given lazy
module. Testing seems to indicate that the CLI uses the global form, but this
should be verified.
Jira issue: FW-629
PR Close#27697
This commit introduces a new mode for the NgtscTestEnvironment which
builds the NgtscProgram and then asks for the list of lazy routes,
instead of running the TS emit phase.
PR Close#27697
This commit introduces the NgModuleRouteAnalyzer & friends, which given
metadata about the NgModules in a program can extract the list of lazy
routes in the same format that the ngtools API uses.
PR Close#27697
This commit changes the partial evaluation mechanism to propagate
DynamicValue errors internally during evaluation, and not to "poison"
entire data structures when a single value is dynamic. For example,
previously if any entry in an array was dynamic, evaluating the entire
array would return DynamicValue. Now, the array is returned with only
the specific dynamic entry as DynamicValue.
Instances of DynamicValue also report the node that was determined to
be dynamic, as well as a potential reason for the dynamic-ness. These
can be nested, so an expression `a + b` may have a DynamicValue that
indicates the 'a' term was DynamicValue, which will itself contain a
reason for the dynamic-ness.
This work was undertaken for the implementation of listLazyRoutes(),
which needs to partially evaluate provider arrays, parts of which are
dynamic and parts of which contain useful information.
PR Close#27697
`ngtsc` currently fails building a flat module out file on Windows because it generates an invalid flat module TypeScript source file. e.g:
```ts
5 export * from './C:\Users\Paul\Desktop\test\src\export';
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
```
This is because `path.posix.relative` does not properly with non-posix paths, and only expects posix paths in order to work.
PR Close#27993
Previous to this change, the isStylingContext() function was improperly
returning true for LContainers because it used the presence of an array
at index 2 to determine whether it was a styling context. Unfortunately,
LContainers also contain arrays at index 2, so this would return a false
positive. This led to other errors down the line because we would treat
nodes with containers as if they already had styling contexts (even if
they did not), so the proper initialization logic for styling contexts
was not run.
This commit fixes the isStylingContext() function to use LCONTAINER_LENGTH
as a marker rather than the presence of an array, which in turn fixes
host bindings to styles on nodes with containers.
PR Close#28221
Resources can be loaded in the context of another file, which
means that the path to the resource file must be resolved
before it can be loaded.
Previously the API of this interface did not allow the client
code to get access to the resolved URL which is used to load
the resource.
Now this API has been refactored so that you must do the
resource URL resolving first and the loading expects a
resolved URL.
PR Close#28199
Destroys the module's injector when an `NgModule` is destroyed which in turn calls the `ngOnDestroy` methods on the instantiated providers.
This PR resolves FW-739.
PR Close#27793
Users might have run the CSS Preprocessor tool *before* the Angular
compiler. For example, we do it that way under Bazel. This means that
the design-time reference is different from the compile-time one - the
input to the Angular compiler is a plain .css file.
We assume that the preprocessor does a trivial 1:1 mapping using the same
basename with a different extension.
PR Close#28166
Due to the fact that animations in Angular are defined in the component metadata,
all animation trigger definitions are localized to the component and are
inaccessible outside of it. Animation host listeners in Ivy are
rendered in the context of the parent component, but the VE renders them
differently. This patch ensures that animation host listeners are
always registered in the sub component's renderer
Jira issue: FW-943
Jira issue: FW-958
PR Close#28210
The current build workflow depends on cross workspace dependency by
installing angular-cli as a Bazel repository. This is not ideal because
it introduces separate node_module directories other than the one
installed by Angular through the yarn_install rule (ngdeps).
This commit removes angular-cli from the Bazel workspace and installs
rollup and @angular-devkit/build-optimizer locally.
PR Close#28215
Prior to this fix Ivy would not execute any animation triggers
that exist as host bindings on an element if it is removed by
the parent template.
PR Close#28162