960 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Pete Bacon Darwin
9188751adc fix(ivy): i18n - do not render message ids unnecessarily (#32867)
In an attempt to be compatible with previous translation files
the Angular compiler was generating instructions that always
included the message id. This was because it was not possible
to accurately re-generate the id from the calls to `$localize()` alone.

In line with https://hackmd.io/EQF4_-atSXK4XWg8eAha2g this
commit changes the compiler so that it only renders ids if they are
"custom" ones provided by the template author.

NOTE:

When translating messages generated by the Angular compiler
from i18n tags in templates, the `$localize.translate()` function
will compute message ids, if no custom id is provided, using a
common digest function that only relies upon the information
available in the `$localize()` calls.

This computed message id will not be the same as the message
ids stored in legacy translation files. Such files will need to be
migrated to use the new common digest function.

This only affects developers who have been trialling `$localize`, have
been calling `loadTranslations()`, and are not exclusively using custom
ids in their templates.

PR Close #32867
2019-10-02 14:52:00 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
d24ade91b8 fix(ivy): i18n - support colons in $localize metadata (#32867)
Metadata blocks are delimited by colons. Previously the code naively just
looked for the next colon in the string as the end marker.

This commit supports escaping colons within the metadata content.
The Angular compiler has been updated to add escaping as required.

PR Close #32867
2019-10-02 14:52:00 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
9b15588188 refactor(ivy): i18n - move marker block serialization to helpers (#32867)
Previously the metadata and placeholder blocks were serialized in
a variety of places. Moreover the code for creating the `LocalizedString`
AST node was doing serialization, which break the separation of concerns.

Now this is all done by the code that renders the AST and is refactored into
helper functions to avoid repeating the behaviour.

PR Close #32867
2019-10-02 14:52:00 -07:00
crisbeto
4e35e348af refactor(ivy): generate ngFactoryDef for injectables (#32433)
With #31953 we moved the factories for components, directives and pipes into a new field called `ngFactoryDef`, however I decided not to do it for injectables, because they needed some extra logic. These changes set up the `ngFactoryDef` for injectables as well.

For reference, the extra logic mentioned above is that for injectables we have two code paths:

1. For injectables that don't configure how they should be instantiated, we create a `factory` that proxies to `ngFactoryDef`:

```
// Source
@Injectable()
class Service {}

// Output
class Service {
  static ngInjectableDef = defineInjectable({
    factory: () => Service.ngFactoryFn(),
  });

  static ngFactoryFn: (t) => new (t || Service)();
}
```

2. For injectables that do configure how they're created, we keep the `ngFactoryDef` and generate the factory based on the metadata:

```
// Source
@Injectable({
  useValue: DEFAULT_IMPL,
})
class Service {}

// Output
export class Service {
  static ngInjectableDef = defineInjectable({
    factory: () => DEFAULT_IMPL,
  });

  static ngFactoryFn: (t) => new (t || Service)();
}
```

PR Close #32433
2019-10-02 13:04:26 -07:00
atscott
04bfe87764 Revert "feat(core): default to dynamic queries (#32720)" (#32966)
This reverts commit 948b01ce55c7874604016bda87187e8a713d8acc.

PR Close #32966
2019-10-02 10:40:24 -07:00
atscott
879ad69602 Revert "feat(core): make static query flag optional (#32686)" (#32965)
This reverts commit 25219baeb4ae037527fc367f37ff6453e352d4a1.

PR Close #32965
2019-10-02 10:39:49 -07:00
crisbeto
25219baeb4 feat(core): make static query flag optional (#32686)
Switches back to having the `static` flag be optional on `ViewChild` and `ContentChild` queries, in preparation for changing its default value.

PR Close #32686
2019-10-02 09:39:05 -07:00
crisbeto
948b01ce55 feat(core): default to dynamic queries (#32720)
These changes switch to defaulting the `static` flag on `ViewChild` and `ContentChild` queries to `false`, in addition to removing the logic that statically determines whether a query is dynamic.

PR Close #32720
2019-10-02 09:38:21 -07:00
Andrew Kushnir
966c2a326a fix(ivy): include ngProjectAs into attributes array (#32784)
Prior to this commit, the `ngProjectAs` attribute was only included with a special flag and in a parsed format. As a result, projected node was missing `ngProjectAs` attribute as well as other attributes added after `ngProjectAs` one. This is problematic since app code might rely on the presence of `ngProjectAs` attribute (for example in CSS). This commit fixes the problem by including `ngProjectAs` into attributes array as a regular attribute and also makes sure that the parsed version of the `ngProjectAs` attribute with a special marker is added after regular attributes (thus we set them correctly at runtime). This change also aligns View Engine and Ivy behavior.

PR Close #32784
2019-09-27 10:12:18 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
b741a1c3e7 fix(ivy): i18n - update the compiler to output MessageIds (#32594)
Now that the `$localize` translations are `MessageId` based the
compiler must render `MessageId`s in its generated `$localize` code.
This is because the `MessageId` used by the compiler is computed
from information that does not get passed through to the `$localize`
tagged string.

For example, the generated code for the following template

```html
<div id="static" i18n-title="m|d" title="introduction"></div>
```

will contain these localization statements

```ts
if (ngI18nClosureMode) {
  /**
    * @desc d
    * @meaning m
    */
  const MSG_EXTERNAL_8809028065680254561$$APP_SPEC_TS_1 = goog.getMsg("introduction");
  I18N_1 = MSG_EXTERNAL_8809028065680254561$$APP_SPEC_TS_1;
}
else {
  I18N_1 = $localize \`:m|d@@8809028065680254561:introduction\`;
}
```

Since `$localize` is not able to accurately regenerate the source-message
(and so the `MessageId`) from the generated code, it must rely upon the
`MessageId` being provided explicitly in the generated code.

The compiler now prepends all localized messages with a "metadata block"
containing the id (and the meaning and description if defined).

Note that this metadata block will also allow translation file extraction
from the compiled code - rather than relying on the legacy ViewEngine
extraction code. (This will be implemented post-v9).

Although these metadata blocks add to the initial code size, compile-time
inlining will completely remove these strings and so will not impact on
production bundle size.

PR Close #32594
2019-09-17 09:17:45 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
357aa4a097 fix(ivy): i18n - use MessageId for matching translations (#32594)
As discussed in https://hackmd.io/33M5Wb-JT7-0fneA0JuHPA `SourceMessage`
strings are not sufficient for matching translations.

This commit updates `@angular/localize` to use `MessageId`s for translation
matching instead.

Also the run-time translation will now log a warning to the console if a
translation is missing.

BREAKING CHANGE:

Translations (loaded via the `loadTranslations()` function) must now use
`MessageId` for the translation key rather than the previous `SourceMessage`
string.

PR Close #32594
2019-09-17 09:17:44 -07:00
Matias Niemelä
4f41473048 refactor(ivy): remove styling state storage and introduce direct style writing (#32591)
This patch is a final major refactor in styling Angular.

This PR includes three main fixes:

All temporary state taht is persisted between template style/class application
and style/class application in host bindings is now removed.
Removes the styling() and stylingApply() instructions.
Introduces a "direct apply" mode that is used apply prop-based
style/class in the event that there are no map-based bindings as
well as property collisions.

PR Close #32259

PR Close #32591
2019-09-16 14:12:48 -07:00
Andrew Kushnir
5328bb223a fix(ivy): avoid unnecessary i18n instructions generation for <ng-template> with structural directives (#32623)
If an <ng-template> contains a structural directive (for example *ngIf), Ngtsc generates extra template function with 1 template instruction call. When <ng-template> tag also contains i18n attribute on it, we generate i18nStart and i18nEnd instructions around it, which is unnecessary and breaking runtime. This commit adds a logic to make sure we do not generate i18n instructions in case only `template` is present.

PR Close #32623
2019-09-13 10:01:55 -07:00
Matias Niemelä
53dbff66d7 revert: refactor(ivy): remove styling state storage and introduce direct style writing (#32259)
This reverts commit 15aeab16207fd6491e296db02501a14f92ff8e97.
2019-09-11 15:24:10 -07:00
Matias Niemelä
15aeab1620 refactor(ivy): remove styling state storage and introduce direct style writing (#32259) (#32596)
This patch is a final major refactor in styling Angular.

This PR includes three main fixes:

All temporary state taht is persisted between template style/class application
and style/class application in host bindings is now removed.
Removes the styling() and stylingApply() instructions.
Introduces a "direct apply" mode that is used apply prop-based
style/class in the event that there are no map-based bindings as
well as property collisions.

PR Close #32259

PR Close #32596
2019-09-11 16:27:10 -04:00
Matias Niemelä
c84c27f7f4 revert: refactor(ivy): remove styling state storage and introduce direct style writing (#32259) 2019-09-10 18:08:05 -04:00
Matias Niemelä
3b37469735 refactor(ivy): remove styling state storage and introduce direct style writing (#32259)
This patch is a final major refactor in styling Angular.

This PR includes three main fixes:

All temporary state taht is persisted between template style/class application
and style/class application in host bindings is now removed.
Removes the styling() and stylingApply() instructions.
Introduces a "direct apply" mode that is used apply prop-based
style/class in the event that there are no map-based bindings as
well as property collisions.

PR Close #32259
2019-09-10 15:54:58 -04:00
crisbeto
664e0015d4 perf(ivy): replace select instruction with advance (#32516)
Replaces the `select` instruction with a new one called `advance`. Instead of the jumping to a specific index, the new instruction goes forward X amount of elements. The advantage of doing this is that it should generate code the compresses better.

PR Close #32516
2019-09-10 06:30:28 -04:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
ea6a2e9f25 fix(ivy): template compiler should render correct $localize placeholder names (#32509)
The `goog.getMsg()` function requires placeholder names to be camelCased.

This is not the case for `$localize`. Here placeholder names need
match what is serialized to translation files.

Specifically such placeholder names keep their casing but have all characters
that are not in `a-z`, `A-Z`, `0-9` and `_` converted to `_`.

PR Close #32509
2019-09-09 19:11:36 -04:00
crisbeto
62d92f8091 fix(ivy): unable to bind to properties that start with class or style (#32421)
Fixes Ivy picking up property bindings that start with `class` or `style` as if they're style bindings.

Fixes #32310

PR Close #32421
2019-09-05 18:10:08 -04:00
Andrew Kushnir
f00d03356f fix(ivy): handle expressions in i18n attributes properly (#32309)
Prior to this commit, complex expressions (that require additional statements to be generated) were handled incorrectly in case they were used in attributes annotated with i18n flags. The problem was caused by the fact that extra statements were not appended to the temporary vars block, so they were missing in generated code. This commit updated the logic to use the `convertPropertyBinding`, which contains the necessary code to append extra statements. The `convertExpressionBinding` function was removed as it duplicates the `convertPropertyBinding` one (for the most part) and is no longer used.

PR Close #32309
2019-09-05 13:35:16 -04:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
a731119f9f fix(ivy): i18n - do not generate jsdoc comments for $localize (#32473)
Previously the template compiler would generate the same jsdoc comment
block for `$localize` as for `goog.getMsg()`. But it turns out that
the closure compiler will complain if the `@desc` and `@meaning`
tags are used for non-`getMsg()` calls.

For now we do not generate the comments for `$localize` calls. They are
not being used at the moment.

In the future it would be good to be able to extract the descriptions and
meanings from the `$localize` calls rather than relying upon the `getMsg()`
calls, which we do now. So we need to find a workaround for this constraint.

PR Close #32473
2019-09-04 15:40:23 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
5d8eb74634 fix(ivy): i18n - handle translated text containing HTML comments (#32475)
Fixes FW-1536

PR Close #32475
2019-09-04 12:48:44 -07:00
Kara Erickson
89434e09c2 refactor(core): move Meta methods that only have one version from DomAdapter (#32408)
PR Close #32408
2019-09-03 11:59:39 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
c024d89448 refactor(ivy): remove i18nLocalize instruction (#31609)
This has been replaced by the `$localize` tag.

PR Close #31609
2019-08-30 12:53:26 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
fa79f51645 refactor(ivy): update the compiler to emit $localize tags (#31609)
This commit changes the Angular compiler (ivy-only) to generate `$localize`
tagged strings for component templates that use `i18n` attributes.

BREAKING CHANGE

Since `$localize` is a global function, it must be included in any applications
that use i18n. This is achieved by importing the `@angular/localize` package
into an appropriate bundle, where it will be executed before the renderer
needs to call `$localize`. For CLI based projects, this is best done in
the `polyfills.ts` file.

```ts
import '@angular/localize';
```

For non-CLI applications this could be added as a script to the index.html
file or another suitable script file.

PR Close #31609
2019-08-30 12:53:26 -07:00
Misko Hevery
8a47b48912 refactor: Move dom_adapter.ts to @angular/common (#32154)
This work is needed in preparation for turning tokens into tree-shakable injectables.

PR Close #32154
2019-08-29 21:51:56 -07:00
Pawel Kozlowski
5635505f2e refactor(ivy): remove unused ɵɵtextBinding instruction (#32345)
PR Close #32345
2019-08-28 21:37:15 -07:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
c885178d5f refactor(ivy): move directive, component and pipe factories to ngFactoryFn (#31953)
Reworks the compiler to output the factories for directives, components and pipes under a new static field called `ngFactoryFn`, instead of the usual `factory` property in their respective defs. This should eventually allow us to inject any kind of decorated class (e.g. a pipe).

**Note:** these changes are the first part of the refactor and they don't include injectables. I decided to leave injectables for a follow-up PR, because there's some more cases we need to handle when it comes to their factories. Furthermore, directives, components and pipes make up most of the compiler output tests that need to be refactored and it'll make follow-up PRs easier to review if the tests are cleaned up now.

This is part of the larger refactor for FW-1468.

PR Close #31953
2019-08-27 13:57:00 -07:00
Alex Rickabaugh
0677cf0cbe feat(ivy): use the schema registry to check DOM bindings (#32171)
Previously, ngtsc attempted to use the .d.ts schema for HTML elements to
check bindings to DOM properties. However, the TypeScript lib.dom.d.ts
schema does not perfectly align with the Angular DomElementSchemaRegistry,
and these inconsistencies would cause issues in apps. There is also the
concern of supporting both CUSTOM_ELEMENTS_SCHEMA and NO_ERRORS_SCHEMA which
would have been very difficult to do in the existing system.

With this commit, the DomElementSchemaRegistry is employed in ngtsc to check
bindings to the DOM. Previous work on producing template diagnostics is used
to support generation of this different kind of error with the same high
quality of error message.

PR Close #32171
2019-08-22 10:12:45 -07:00
Miško Hevery
64770571b2 perf: don't create holey arrays (#32155)
Don't use `Array` constructor with the size value (ex. `new Array(5)`) - this will create a `HOLEY_ELEMENTS` array (even if this array is filled in later on!);

https://v8.dev/blog/elements-kinds
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/32054170/how-to-resize-an-array

PR Close #32155
2019-08-21 08:27:43 -07:00
Alex Rickabaugh
2b64031ddc refactor(ivy): remove the tsc passthrough option (#32219)
This option makes ngc behave as tsc, and was originally implemented before
ngtsc existed. It was designed so we could build JIT-only versions of
Angular packages to begin testing Ivy early, and is not used at all in our
current setup.

PR Close #32219
2019-08-20 16:41:08 -07:00
atscott
cfed0c0cf1 fix(ivy): Support selector-less directive as base classes (#32125)
Following #31379, this adds support for directives without a selector to
Ivy.

PR Close #32125
2019-08-20 09:56:54 -07:00
Alex Rickabaugh
4055150910 feat(compiler): allow selector-less directives as base classes (#31379)
In Angular today, the following pattern works:

```typescript
export class BaseDir {
  constructor(@Inject(ViewContainerRef) protected vcr: ViewContainerRef) {}
}

@Directive({
  selector: '[child]',
})
export class ChildDir extends BaseDir {
  // constructor inherited from BaseDir
}
```

A decorated child class can inherit a constructor from an undecorated base
class, so long as the base class has metadata of its own (for JIT mode).
This pattern works regardless of metadata in AOT.

In Angular Ivy, this pattern does not work: without the @Directive
annotation identifying the base class as a directive, information about its
constructor parameters will not be captured by the Ivy compiler. This is a
result of Ivy's locality principle, which is the basis behind a number of
compilation optimizations.

As a solution, @Directive() without a selector will be interpreted as a
"directive base class" annotation. Such a directive cannot be declared in an
NgModule, but can be inherited from. To implement this, a few changes are
made to the ngc compiler:

* the error for a selector-less directive is now generated when an NgModule
  declaring it is processed, not when the directive itself is processed.
* selector-less directives are not tracked along with other directives in
  the compiler, preventing other errors (like their absence in an NgModule)
  from being generated from them.

PR Close #31379
2019-08-14 12:03:05 -07:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
914900a561 refactor(ivy): remove load instruction (#32067)
These changes remove the `ɵɵload` instruction which isn't being generated anymore.

PR Close #32067
2019-08-12 12:55:18 -07:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
4ea3e7e000 refactor(ivy): combine query load instructions (#32100)
Combines the `loadViewQuery` and `loadContentQuery` instructions since they have the exact same internal logic. Based on a discussion here: https://github.com/angular/angular/pull/32067#pullrequestreview-273001730

PR Close #32100
2019-08-12 10:32:08 -07:00
Kara Erickson
37de490e23 Revert "feat(compiler): allow selector-less directives as base classes (#31379)" (#32089)
This reverts commit f90c7a9df014d79a1a4065271c54f3dd4e758eda due to breakages in G3.

PR Close #32089
2019-08-09 18:20:53 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
0ddf0c4895 fix(compiler): do not remove whitespace wrapping i18n expansions (#31962)
Similar to interpolation, we do not want to completely remove whitespace
nodes that are siblings of an expansion.

For example, the following template

```html
<div>
  <strong>items left<strong> {count, plural, =1 {item} other {items}}
</div>
```

was being collapsed to

```html
<div><strong>items left<strong>{count, plural, =1 {item} other {items}}</div>
```

which results in the text looking like

```
items left4
```

instead it should be collapsed to

```html
<div><strong>items left<strong> {count, plural, =1 {item} other {items}}</div>
```

which results in the text looking like

```
items left 4
```

---

**Analysis of the code and manual testing has shown that this does not cause
the generated ids to change, so there is no breaking change here.**

PR Close #31962
2019-08-09 12:03:50 -07:00
Alex Rickabaugh
f90c7a9df0 feat(compiler): allow selector-less directives as base classes (#31379)
In Angular today, the following pattern works:

```typescript
export class BaseDir {
  constructor(@Inject(ViewContainerRef) protected vcr: ViewContainerRef) {}
}

@Directive({
  selector: '[child]',
})
export class ChildDir extends BaseDir {
  // constructor inherited from BaseDir
}
```

A decorated child class can inherit a constructor from an undecorated base
class, so long as the base class has metadata of its own (for JIT mode).
This pattern works regardless of metadata in AOT.

In Angular Ivy, this pattern does not work: without the @Directive
annotation identifying the base class as a directive, information about its
constructor parameters will not be captured by the Ivy compiler. This is a
result of Ivy's locality principle, which is the basis behind a number of
compilation optimizations.

As a solution, @Directive() without a selector will be interpreted as a
"directive base class" annotation. Such a directive cannot be declared in an
NgModule, but can be inherited from. To implement this, a few changes are
made to the ngc compiler:

* the error for a selector-less directive is now generated when an NgModule
  declaring it is processed, not when the directive itself is processed.
* selector-less directives are not tracked along with other directives in
  the compiler, preventing other errors (like their absence in an NgModule)
  from being generated from them.

PR Close #31379
2019-08-09 10:45:22 -07:00
JoostK
3a2b195a58 feat(ivy): translate type-check diagnostics to their original source (#30181)
PR Close #30181
2019-07-25 16:36:32 -07:00
JoostK
489cef6ea2 feat(ivy): include value spans for attributes, variables and references (#30181)
Template AST nodes for (bound) attributes, variables and references will
now retain a reference to the source span of their value, which allows
for more accurate type check diagnostics.

PR Close #30181
2019-07-25 16:36:32 -07:00
crisbeto
3d7303efc0 perf(ivy): avoid extra parameter in query instructions (#31667)
Currently we always generate the `read` parameter for the view and content query instructions, however since most of the time the `read` parameter won't be set, we'll end up generating `null` which adds 5 bytes for each query when minified. These changes make it so that the `read` parameter only gets generated if it has a value.

PR Close #31667
2019-07-24 14:37:51 -07:00
Andrew Kushnir
24ca582bc5 perf(compiler): avoid copying from prototype while cloning an object (#31638)
This commit updates the `_clone` function of the `_ApplySourceSpanTransformer` class, where the for-in loop was used, resulting in copying from prototype to own properties, thus consuming more memory. Prior to NodeJS 12 (V8 versions before 7.4) there was an optimization that was improving the situation and since that logic was removed in favor of other optimizations, the situation with memory consumption caused by the for-in loop got worse. This commit adds a check to make sure we copy only own properties over to cloned object.

Closes #31627.

PR Close #31638
2019-07-23 15:49:30 -07:00
crisbeto
0aff4a6919 fix(ivy): incorrect ChangeDetectorRef injected into pipes used in component inputs (#31438)
When injecting a `ChangeDetectorRef` into a pipe, the expected result is that the ref will be tied to the component in which the pipe is being used. This works for most cases, however when a pipe is used inside a property binding of a component (see test case as an example), the current `TNode` is pointing to component's host so we end up injecting the inner component's view. These changes fix the issue by only looking up the component view of the `TNode` if the `TNode` is a parent.

This PR resolves FW-1419.

PR Close #31438
2019-07-23 15:46:23 -07:00
Ayaz Hafiz
f65db20c6d feat(ivy): record absolute position of template expressions (#31391)
Currently, template expressions and statements have their location
recorded relative to the HTML element they are in, with no handle to
absolute location in a source file except for a line/column location.
However, the line/column location is also not entirely accurate, as it
points an entire semantic expression, and not necessarily the start of
an expression recorded by the expression parser.

To support record of the source code expressions originate from, add a
new `sourceSpan` field to `ASTWithSource` that records the absolute byte
offset of an expression within a source code.

Implement part 2 of [refactoring template parsing for
stability](https://hackmd.io/@X3ECPVy-RCuVfba-pnvIpw/BkDUxaW84/%2FMA1oxh6jRXqSmZBcLfYdyw?type=book).

PR Close #31391
2019-07-22 09:48:35 -07:00
Matias Niemelä
9c954ebc62 refactor(ivy): make styling instructions use the new styling algorithm (#30742)
This commit is the final patch of the ivy styling algorithm refactor.
This patch swaps functionality from the old styling mechanism to the
new refactored code by changing the instruction code the compiler
generates and by pointing the runtime instruction code to the new
styling algorithm.

PR Close #30742
2019-07-19 16:40:40 -07:00
Pete Bacon Darwin
376ad9c3cd refactor(ivy): remove deep imports into the compiler (#31376)
The compiler-cli should only reference code that can
be imported from the main entry-point of compiler.

PR Close #31376
2019-07-18 14:23:32 -07:00
Paul Gschwendtner
647d7bdd88 refactor: fix typescript strict flag failures in all tests (#30993)
Fixes all TypeScript failures caused by enabling the `--strict`
flag for test source files. We also want to enable the strict
options for tests as the strictness enforcement improves the
overall codehealth, unveiled common issues and additionally it
allows us to enable `strict` in the `tsconfig.json` that is picked
up by IDE's.

PR Close #30993
2019-07-18 14:21:26 -07:00
Paul Gschwendtner
012b535147 refactor(compiler): ensure compatibility with typescript strict flag (#30993)
As part of FW-1265, the `@angular/compiler` package is made compatible
with the TypeScript `--strict` flag. This already unveiled a few bugs,
so the strictness flag seems to help with increasing the overall code health.

Read more about the strict flag [here](https://www.typescriptlang.org/docs/handbook/compiler-options.html)

PR Close #30993
2019-07-18 14:21:25 -07:00
crisbeto
12fd06916b fix(ivy): don't match directives against attribute bindings (#31541)
Fixes Ivy matching directives against attribute bindings (e.g. `[attr.some-directive]="foo"`). Works by excluding attribute bindings from the attributes array during compilation. This has the added benefit of generating less code.

**Note:** My initial approach to implementing this was to have a different marker for attribute bindings so that they can be ignored when matching directives, however as I was implementing it I realized that the attributes in that array were only used for directive matching (as far as I could tell). I decided to drop the attribute bindings completely, because it results in less generated code.

PR Close #31541
2019-07-16 23:59:13 -04:00