python-peps/pep-0263.txt

PEP: 0263
Title: Defining Python Source Code Encodings
Version: $Revision$
Author: mal@lemburg.com (Marc-Andr<64> Lemburg)
Status: Draft
Type: Standards Track
Python-Version: 2.3
Created: 06-Jun-2001
Last-Modified:
Post-History: 

Abstract

    This PEP proposes to introduce a syntax to declare the encoding of
    a Python source file. The encoding information is then used by the
    Python parser to interpret the file using the given encoding. Most
    notably this enhances the interpretation of Unicode literals in
    the source code and makes it possible to write Unicode literals
    using e.g. UTF-8 directly in an Unicode aware editor.

Problem

    In Python 2.1, Unicode literals can only be written using the
    Latin-1 based encoding "unicode-escape". This makes the
    programming environment rather unfriendly to Python users who live
    and work in non-Latin-1 locales such as many of the Asian 
    countries. Programmers can write their 8-bit strings using the
    favourite encoding, but are bound to the "unicode-escape" encoding
    for Unicode literals.

Proposed Solution

    I propose to make the Python source code encoding both visible and
    changeable on a per-source file basis by using a special comment
    at the top of the file to declare the encoding.

    To make Python aware of this encoding declaration a number of
    concept changes are necessary with repect to the handling of
    Python source code data.

Defining the Encoding

    Python will default to ASCII as standard encoding if no other
    encoding hints are given.

    To define a source code encoding, a magic comment must
    be placed into the source files either as first or second
    line in the file:    

          #!/usr/bin/python
          # -*- coding: <encoding name> -*-

    More precise, the first or second line must match the regular
    expression "coding[:=]\s*([\w-_.]+)". The first group of this
    expression is then interpreted as encoding name. If the encoding
    is unknown to Python, an error is raised during compilation.

    To aid with platforms such as Windows, which add Unicode BOM marks
    to the beginning of Unicode files, the UTF-8 signature
    '\xef\xbb\xbf' will be interpreted as 'utf-8' encoding as well
    (even if no magic encoding comment is given).

    If a source file uses both the UTF-8 BOM mark signature and a
    magic encoding comment, the only allowed encoding for the comment
    is 'utf-8'.  Any other encoding will cause an error.

Concepts

    The PEP is based on the following concepts which would have to be
    implemented to enable usage of such a magic comment:

    1. The complete Python source file should use a single encoding.
       Embedding of differently encoded data is not allowed and will
       result in a decoding error during compilation of the Python
       source code.

       Any encoding which allows processing the first two lines in the
       way indicated above is allowed as source code encoding, this
       includes ASCII compatible encodings as well as certain
       multi-byte encodings such as Shift_JIS. It does not include
       encodings which use two or more bytes for all characters like
       e.g. UTF-16. The reason for this is to keep the encoding
       detection algorithm in the tokenizer simple.

    2. Handling of escape sequences should continue to work as it does 
       now, but with all possible source code encodings, that is
       standard string literals (both 8-bit and Unicode) are subject to 
       escape sequence expansion while raw string literals only expand
       a very small subset of escape sequences.

    3. Python's tokenizer/compiler combo will need to be updated to
       work as follows:

       1. read the file

       2. decode it into Unicode assuming a fixed per-file encoding

       3. tokenize the Unicode content

       4. compile it, creating Unicode objects from the given Unicode data
          and creating string objects from the Unicode literal data
          by first reencoding the Unicode data into 8-bit string data
          using the given file encoding

       5. variable names and other identifiers will be reencoded into
          8-bit strings using the file encoding to assure backward
          compatibility with the existing implementation

       Note that Python identifiers are restricted to the ASCII
       subset of the encoding.

Implementation

    Since changing the Python tokenizer/parser combination will
    require major changes in the internals of the interpreter and
    enforcing the use of magic comments in source code files which
    place non-ASCII characters in string literals, comments
    and Unicode literals, the proposed solution should be implemented
    in two phases:

    1. Implement the magic comment detection, but only apply the
       detected encoding to Unicode literals in the source file.

       If no magic comment is used, Python should continue to
       use the standard [raw-]unicode-escape codecs for Unicode
       literals.

       In addition to this step and to aid in the transition to
       explicit encoding declaration, the tokenizer must check the
       complete source file for compliance with the declared
       encoding. If the source file does not properly decode, a single
       warning is generated per file.

    2. Change the tokenizer/compiler base string type from char* to
       Py_UNICODE* and apply the encoding to the complete file.

       Source files which fail to decode cause an error to be raised
       during compilation.

       The builtin compile() API will be enhanced to accept Unicode as
       input. 8-bit string input is subject to the standard procedure
       for encoding detection as decsribed above.

    Martin v. Loewis is working on a patch which implements phase 1.
    See [1] for details.

Scope

    This PEP intends to provide an upgrade path from th current
    (more-or-less) undefined source code encoding situation to a more
    robust and portable definition.

References

    [1] Phase 1 implementation:
        http://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&atid=305470&aid=526840&group_id=5470

History

    1.10 and above: see CVS history
    1.8: Added '.' to the coding RE.
    1.7: Added warnings to phase 1 implementation. Replaced the
         Latin-1 default encoding with the interpreter's default
         encoding. Added tweaks to compile().
    1.4 - 1.6: Minor tweaks
    1.3: Worked in comments by Martin v. Loewis: 
         UTF-8 BOM mark detection, Emacs style magic comment,
         two phase approach to the implementation

Copyright

    This document has been placed in the public domain.


Local Variables:
mode: indented-text
indent-tabs-mode: nil
End: