python-peps/peps/pep-0042.rst

PEP: 42
Title: Feature Requests
Author: Jeremy Hylton <jeremy@alum.mit.edu>
Status: Withdrawn
Type: Process
Created: 12-Sep-2000
Post-History:

.. withdrawn::

   It is `obsolete`_.
   All new feature requests should  either go to the `Python bug tracker`_
   for very simple requests or the `Ideas Discourse category`_ for
   everything else.  The rest of this document is retained for historical
   purposes only.


Introduction
============

This PEP contains a list of feature requests that may be considered
for future versions of Python.  Large feature requests should not be
included here, but should be described in separate PEPs; however a
large feature request that doesn't have its own PEP can be listed here
until its own PEP is created.  See :pep:`0` for details.

This PEP was created to allow us to close bug reports that are really
feature requests.  Marked as Open, they distract from the list of real
bugs (which should ideally be less than a page).  Marked as Closed,
they tend to be forgotten.  The procedure now is:  if a bug report is
really a feature request, add the feature request to this PEP; mark
the bug as "feature request", "later", and "closed"; and add a comment
to the bug saying that this is the case (mentioning the PEP
explicitly).  It is also acceptable to move large feature requests
directly from the bugs database to a separate PEP.

This PEP should really be separated into four different categories
(categories due to Laura Creighton):

1. BDFL rejects as a bad idea.  Don't come back with it.

2. BDFL will put in if somebody writes the code.  (Or at any rate,
   BDFL will say 'change this and I will put it in' if you show up
   with code.)

   possibly divided into:

      a) BDFL would really like to see some code!

      b) BDFL is never going to be enthusiastic about this, but
         will work it in when it's easy.

3. If you show up with code, BDFL will make a pronouncement.  It might
   be ICK.

4. This is too vague.  This is rejected, but only on the grounds of
   vagueness.  If you like this enhancement, make a new PEP.


Core Language / Builtins
========================

* The parser should handle more deeply nested parse trees.

  The following will fail -- ``eval("["*50`` + ``"]"*50)`` -- because
  the parser has a hard-coded limit on stack size.  This limit should
  be raised or removed.  Removal would be hard because the current
  compiler can overflow the C stack if the nesting is too deep.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue215555

* Non-accidental IEEE-754 support (Infs, NaNs, settable traps, etc).
  Big project.

* Windows:  Trying to create (or even access) files with certain
  magic names can hang or crash Windows systems.  This is really a
  bug in the OSes, but some apps try to shield users from it.  When
  it happens, the symptoms are very confusing.

  Hang using files named prn.txt, etc https://bugs.python.org/issue481171

* eval and free variables: It might be useful if there was a way to
  pass bindings for free variables to eval when a code object with
  free variables is passed. https://bugs.python.org/issue443866

Standard Library
================

* The urllib module should support proxies which require
  authentication.  See SourceForge bug #210619 for information:

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210619

* os.rename() should be modified to handle EXDEV errors on platforms
  that don't allow rename() to operate across filesystem boundaries
  by copying the file over and removing the original. Linux is one
  system that requires this treatment.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue212317

* signal handling doesn't always work as expected.  E.g. if
  sys.stdin.readline() is interrupted by a (returning) signal
  handler, it returns "".  It would be better to make it raise an
  exception (corresponding to EINTR) or to restart.  But these
  changes would have to applied to all places that can do blocking
  interruptible I/O.  So it's a big project.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210599

* Extend Windows utime to accept directory paths.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue214245

* Extend copy.py to module & function types.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue214553

* Better checking for bad input to ``marshal.load*().``

  https://bugs.python.org/issue214754

* rfc822.py should be more lenient than the spec in the types of
  address fields it parses.  Specifically, an invalid address of the
  form "From: Amazon.com <delivers-news2@amazon.com>" should be
  parsed correctly.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210678

* cgi.py's FieldStorage class should be more conservative with memory
  in the face of large binary file uploads.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210674

  There are two issues here: first, because
  read_lines_to_outerboundary() uses readline() it is possible that a
  large amount of data will be read into memory for a binary file
  upload.  This should probably look at the Content-Type header of the
  section and do a chunked read if it's a binary type.

  The second issue was related to the self.lines attribute, which was
  removed in revision 1.56 of cgi.py (see also):

  https://bugs.python.org/issue219806

* urllib should support proxy definitions that contain just the host
  and port

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210849

* urlparse should be updated to comply with :rfc:`2396`, which defines
  optional parameters for each segment of the path.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210834

* The exceptions raised by pickle and cPickle are currently
  different; these should be unified (probably the exceptions should
  be defined in a helper module that's imported by both). [No bug
  report; I just thought of this.]

* More standard library routines should support Unicode.  For
  example, urllib.quote() could convert Unicode strings to UTF-8 and
  then do the usual %HH conversion.  But this is not the only one!

  https://bugs.python.org/issue216716

* There should be a way to say that you don't mind if ``str()`` or
  ``__str__()`` return a Unicode string object.  Or a different function
  -- ``ustr()`` has been proposed.  Or something...

  http://sf.net/patch/?func=detailpatch&patch_id=101527&group_id=5470

* Killing a thread from another thread.  Or maybe sending a signal.
  Or maybe raising an asynchronous exception.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue221115

* The debugger (pdb) should understand packages.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210631

* Jim Fulton suggested the following:

  ::

    I wonder if it would be a good idea to have a new kind of
    temporary file that stored data in memory unless:

    - The data exceeds some size, or

    - Somebody asks for a fileno.

    Then the cgi module (and other apps) could use this thing in a
    uniform way.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue415692

* Jim Fulton pointed out that binascii's b2a_base64() function has
  situations where it makes sense not to append a newline, or to
  append something else than a newline.

  Proposal:

  - add an optional argument giving the delimiter string to be
    appended, defaulting to "\\n"

  - possibly special-case None as the delimiter string to avoid adding
    the pad bytes too???

  https://bugs.python.org/issue415694

* pydoc should be integrated with the HTML docs, or at least be able
  to link to them.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue405554

* Distutils should deduce dependencies for .c and .h files.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue472881

* asynchat is buggy in the face of multithreading.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue595217

* It would be nice if the higher level modules (httplib, smtplib,
  nntplib, etc.) had options for setting socket timeouts.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue723287

* The curses library is missing two important calls: newterm() and
  delscreen()

  https://bugs.python.org/issue665572, http://bugs.debian.org/175590

* It would be nice if the built-in SSL socket type could be used for
  non-blocking SSL I/O.  Currently packages such as Twisted which
  implement async servers using SSL have to require third-party
  packages such as pyopenssl.

* reST as a standard library module

* The import lock could use some redesign.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue683658

* A nicer API to open text files, replacing the ugly (in some
  people's eyes) "U" mode flag.  There's a proposal out there to have
  a new built-in type textfile(filename, mode, encoding). (Shouldn't
  it have a bufsize argument too?)

* Support new widgets and/or parameters for Tkinter

* For a class defined inside another class, the __name__ should be
  "outer.inner", and pickling should work.  (GvR is no longer certain
  this is easy or even right.)

  https://bugs.python.org/issue633930

* Decide on a clearer deprecation policy (especially for modules) and
  act on it.

  https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2002-April/023165.html

* Provide alternatives for common uses of the types module; Skip
  Montanaro has posted a proto-PEP for this idea:

  https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2002-May/024346.html

* Use pending deprecation for the types and string modules.  This
  requires providing alternatives for the parts that aren't covered
  yet (e.g. string.whitespace and types.TracebackType). It seems we
  can't get consensus on this.

* Lazily tracking tuples?

  https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2002-May/023926.html
  https://bugs.python.org/issue558745

* Make 'as' a keyword.  It has been a pseudo-keyword long enough.
  (It's deprecated in 2.5, and will become a keyword in 2.6.)


C API wishes
============

* Add C API functions to help Windows users who are building embedded
  applications where the FILE \* structure does not match the FILE \*
  the interpreter was compiled with.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210821

  See this bug report for a specific suggestion that will allow a
  Borland C++ builder application to interact with a python.dll build
  with MSVC.


Tools
=====

* Python could use a GUI builder.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue210820


Building and Installing
=======================

* Modules/makesetup should make sure the 'config.c' file it generates
  from the various Setup files, is valid C. It currently accepts
  module names with characters that are not allowable in Python or C
  identifiers.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue216326

* Building from source should not attempt to overwrite the
  Include/graminit.h and Parser/graminit.c files, at least for people
  downloading a source release rather than working from Subversion or
  snapshots.  Some people find this a problem in unusual build
  environments.

  https://bugs.python.org/issue219221

* The configure script has probably grown a bit crufty with age and
  may not track autoconf's more recent features very well.  It should
  be looked at and possibly cleaned up.

  https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2004-January/041790.html

* Make Python compliant to the FHS (the Filesystem Hierarchy
  Standard)

  http://bugs.python.org/issue588756

.. _`Python bug tracker`: https://github.com/python/cpython/issues
.. _`Ideas Discourse category`: https://discuss.python.org/c/ideas/6
.. _`obsolete`: https://github.com/python/peps/pull/108#issuecomment-249603204