python-peps/pep-0385.txt

PEP: 385
Title: Migrating from Subversion to Mercurial
Version: $Revision$
Last-Modified: $Date$
Author: Dirkjan Ochtman <dirkjan@ochtman.nl>,
        Antoine Pitrou <solipsis@pitrou.net>,
        Georg Brandl <georg@python.org>
Status: Active
Type: Process
Content-Type: text/x-rst
Created: 25-May-2009


Motivation
==========

After having decided to switch to the Mercurial DVCS, the actual
migration still has to be performed.  In the case of an important
piece of infrastructure like the version control system for a large,
distributed project like Python, this is a significant effort.  This
PEP is an attempt to describe the steps that must be taken for further
discussion.  It's somewhat similar to `PEP 347`_, which discussed the
migration to SVN.

To make the most of hg, we would like to make a high-fidelity
conversion, such that (a) as much of the svn metadata as possible is
retained, and (b) all metadata is converted to formats that are common
in Mercurial.  This way, tools written for Mercurial can be optimally
used.  In order to do this, we want to use the `hgsubversion`_
software to do an initial conversion.  This hg extension is focused on
providing high-quality conversion from Subversion to Mercurial for use
in two-way correspondence, meaning it doesn't throw away as much
available metadata as other solutions.

Such a conversion also seems like a good time to reconsider the
contents of the repository and determine if some things are still
valuable.  In this spirit, the following sections also propose
discarding some of the older metadata.

.. _PEP 347: http://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0347/
.. _hgsubversion: http://bitbucket.org/durin42/hgsubversion/


Timeline
========

The current schedule for conversion milestones:

- 2011-02-24: availability of a test repo at hg.python.org

  Test commits will be allowed (and encouraged) from all committers to
  the Subversion repository.  The test repository and all test commits
  will be removed once the final conversion is done.  The server-side
  hooks will be installed for the test repository, in order to test
  buildbot, diff-email and whitespace checking integration.

- 2010-03-05: final conversion (tentative)

  Commits to the Subversion branches now maintained in Mercurial will
  be blocked.  Developers should refrain from pushing to the Mercurial
  repositories until all infrastructure is ensured to work after their
  switch over to the new repository.


Todo list
=========

The current list of issues to resolve at various steps in the
conversion is kept `in the pymigr repo`_.

.. _in the pymigr repo: http://hg.python.org/pymigr/file/tip/todo.txt


Transition plan
===============

Branch strategy
---------------

Mercurial has two basic ways of using branches: cloned branches, where
each branch is kept in a separate repository, and named branches,
where each revision keeps metadata to note on which branch it belongs.
The former makes it easier to distinguish branches, at the expense of
requiring more disk space on the client.  The latter makes it a little
easier to switch between branches, but all branch names are a
persistent part of history. [1]_

Differences between named branches and cloned branches:

* Tags in a different (maintenance) clone aren't available in the
  local clone
* Clones with named branches will be larger, since they contain more
  data

We propose to use named branches for release branches and adopt cloned
branches for feature branches.

.. with one exception to this rule: the 3.x branches will be kept in
.. separate clones from the 2.x branches.  I think this provides an
.. optimal hybrid approach for Python's uses of branching.


History management
------------------

In order to minimize the loss of information due to the conversion, we
propose to provide several repositories as a conversion result:

* A repository trimmed to the mainline trunk (and py3k), as well as
  past and present maintenance branches -- this is called the
  "working" repo and is where development continues.  This repository has
  all the history needed for development work, including annotating
  source files with changes back up to 1990 and other common history-digging
  operations.

  The ``default`` branch in that repo is what is known as ``py3k`` in
  Subversion, while the Subversion trunk lives on with the branch name
  ``trunk``; however in Mercurial this branch will be closed.  Release
  branches are named after their major.minor version, e.g. ``3.2``.

* A repository with the full, unedited conversion of the Subversion
  repository (actually, its /python subdirectory) -- this is called
  the "historic" or "archive" repo and will be offered as a read-only
  resource. [2]_

* One more repository per active feature branch; "active" means that
  at least one core developer asks for the branch to be provided.  Each
  such repository will contain both the feature branch and all ancestor
  changesets from mainline (coming from ``trunk`` and/or ``py3k`` in SVN).

Since all branches are present in the historic repo, they can later be
extracted as separate repositories at any time should it prove to be
necessary.

.. Converting branches
.. -------------------

.. There are quite a lot of branches in SVN's branches directory.  We
.. propose to clean this up a bit, by following this basic strategy:

.. * Keep all release (maintenance) branches
.. * Discard branches that haven't been touched in 18 months, unless
..   somone indicates there's still interest in such a branch
.. * Keep branches that have been touched in the last 18 months, unless
..   someone indicates the branch can be deprecated

.. There's a `branch map`_ available that shows info about each branch:

.. * keep-clone means we'll keep that branch in a separate clone
.. * keep-named means we'll keep that branch as a named branch in one of
..   the clones
.. * strip means we won't keep that branch
.. * streamed-merge means that it got merged by committing several new
..   revisions to the other branch
.. * merged-r* means the branch got merged in the named revision
.. * merges? means we haven't checked/found out yet whether that branch
..   was ever merged
.. * ? means that your input would be even more helpful than for the
..   other items
.. * some items have no action yet, feel free to treat that as just '?'

.. .. _branch map: http://hg.python.org/pymigr/file/tip/all-branches.txt


Converting tags
---------------

The SVN tags directory contains a lot of old stuff.  Some of these are
not, in fact, full tags, but contain only a smaller subset of the
repository.  All release tags will be kept; other tags will be
included based on requests from the developer community.  We propose
to make the tag naming scheme consistent, in this style: ``v3.2.1a2``.


Author map
----------

In order to provide user names the way they are common in hg (in the
'First Last <user@example.org>' format), we need an author map to map
cvs and svn user names to real names and their email addresses.  We
have a complete version of such a map in my `migration tools
repository`_.  The email addresses in it might be out of date; that's
bound to happen, although it would be nice to try and have as many
people as possible review it for addresses that are out of date.  The
current version also still seems to contain some encoding problems.

.. _migration tools repository: http://hg.python.org/pymigr/


Generating .hgignore
--------------------

The .hgignore file can be used in Mercurial repositories to help
ignore files that are not eligible for version control.  It does this
by employing several possible forms of pattern matching.  The current
Python repository already includes a rudimentary .hgignore file to
help with using the hg mirrors.

Since the current Python repository already includes a .hgignore file
(for use with hg mirrors), we'll just use that.  Generating full
history of the file was debated but deemed impractical (because it's
relatively hard with fairly little gain, since ignoring is less
important for older revisions).


Repository size
---------------

A bare conversion result of the current Python repository weighs 1.9
GB; although this is smaller than the Subversion repository (2.7 GB)
it is not feasible.

The size becomes more manageable by the trimming applied to the
working repository, and by a process called "revlog reordering" that
optimizes the layout of internal Mercurial storage very efficiently.

After all optimizations done, the size of the working repository is
around 180 MB on disk.  The amount of data transferred over the
network when cloning is estimated to be around 80 MB.


Other repositories
------------------

There are a number of other projects hosted in svn.python.org's
"projects" repository.  The "peps" directory will be converted along
with the main Python one.  Richard Tew has indicated that he'd like the
Stackless repository to also be converted.  What other projects in the
svn.python.org repository should be converted?

There's now an initial stab at converting the Jython repository.  The
current tip of hgsubversion unfortunately fails at some point.
Pending investigation.

Other repositories that would like to converted to Mercurial can
announce themselves to me after the main Python migration is done, and
I'll take care of their needs.


Infrastructure
==============

hg-ssh
------

Developers should access the repositories through ssh, similar to the
current setup.  Public keys can be used to grant people access to a
shared hg@ account.  A hgwebdir instance also has been set up at
``hg.python.org`` for easy browsing and read-only access.  It is
configured so that developers can trivially start new clones (for
longer-term features that profit from development in a separate
repository).

Hooks
-----

A number of hooks is currently in use.  The hg equivalents for these
should be developed and deployed.  The following hooks are being used:

* check whitespace: a hook to reject commits in case the whitespace
  doesn't match the rules for the Python codebase.  In a changegroup,
  only the tip is checked (this allows cleanup commits for changes
  pulled from third-party repos).  We can also offer a whitespace hook
  for use with client-side repositories that people can use; it could
  either warn about whitespace issues and/or truncate trailing
  whitespace from changed lines.

* commit mails: Emails will include diffs for each changeset committed
  against the repository.

* buildbots: both the regular and the community build masters must be
  notified.

The `hooks repository`_ contains ports of these server-side hooks to
Mercurial.  One additional hook could be beneficial:

* check contributors: in the current setup, all changesets bear the
  username of committers, who must have signed the contributor
  agreement.  We might want to use a hook to check if the committer is
  a contributor if we keep a list of registered contributors.  Then,
  the hook might warn users that push a group of revisions containing
  changesets from unknown contributors.

.. _hooks repository: http://hg.python.org/hooks/


End-of-line conversions
-----------------------

Discussion about the lack of end-of-line conversion support in
Mercurial, which was provided initially by the win32text extension,
led to the development of the new eol extension that supports a
versioned management of line-ending conventions on a file-by-file
basis, akin to Subversion's ``svn:eol-style`` properties.  This
information is kept in a versioned file called ``.hgeol``, and such a
file has already been checked into the Subversion repository.

A hook on the server side that turns down any changegroup or changeset
introducing inconsistent newline data can still be implemented, if
deemed necessary.


hgwebdir
--------

A more or less stock hgwebdir installation should be set up.  We might
want to come up with a style to match the Python website.

A `small WSGI application`_ has been written that can look up
Subversion revisions and redirect to the appropriate hgweb page for
the given changeset, regardless in which repository the converted
revision ended up (since one big Subversion repository is converted
into several Mercurial repositories).  It can also look up Mercurial
changesets by their hexadecimal ID.

.. _small WSGI application: http://hg.python.org/pymigr/file/tip/hglookup.py


roundup
-------

By pointing Roundup to the URL of the lookup script mentioned above,
links to SVN revisions will continue to work, and links to Mercurial
changesets can be created as well, without having to give repository
*and* changeset ID.


After migration
===============

Where to get code
-----------------

After migration, the hgwebdir will live at hg.python.org.  This is an
accepted standard for many organizations, and an easy parallel to
svn.python.org.  The working repo might live at
http://hg.python.org/cpython/, for example, with the archive repo at
http://hg.python.org/cpython-archive/.  For write access, developers
will have to use ssh, which could be ssh://hg@hg.python.org/cpython/.

code.python.org was also proposed as the hostname.  We think that
using the VCS name in the hostname is good because it prevents
confusion: it should be clear that you can't use svn or bzr for
hg.python.org.

hgwebdir can already provide tarballs for every changeset.  This
obviates the need for daily snapshots; we can just point users to
tip.tar.gz instead, meaning they will get the latest.  If desired, we
could even use buildbot results to point to the last good changeset.


Python-specific documentation
-----------------------------

hg comes with good built-in documentation (available through hg help)
and a `wiki`_ that's full of useful information and recipes.

In addition to that, the recently overhauled `Python Developer's
Guide`_ already has a branch with instructions for Mercurial instead
of Subversion; an online `build of this branch`_ is also available.

.. _Python Developer's Guide: http://docs.python.org/devguide/
.. _build of this branch: http://potrou.net/hgdevguide/
.. _wiki: http://mercurial.selenic.com/wiki/


Proposed workflow
-----------------

We propose two workflows for the migration of patches between several
branches.

For migration within 2.x or 3.x branches, we propose a patch always
gets committed to the oldest branch where it applies first.  Then, the
resulting changeset can be merged using hg merge to all newer branches
within that series (2.x or 3.x).  If it does not apply as-is to the
newer branch, hg revert can be used to easily revert to the
new-branch-native head, patch in some alternative version of the patch
(or none, if it's not applicable), then commit the merge.  The premise
here is that all changesets from an older branch within the series are
eventually merged to all newer branches within the series.

The upshot is that this provides for the most painless merging
procedure.  This means that in the general case, people have to think
about the oldest branch to which the patch should be applied before
actually applying it.  Usually, that is one of only two branches: the
latest maintenance branch and the trunk, except for security fixes
applicable to older branches in security-fix-only mode.

For merging bug fixes from the 3.x to the 2.7 maintenance branch (2.6
and 2.5 are in security-fix-only mode and their maintenance will
continue in the Subversion repository), changesets should be
transplanted (not merged) in some other way.  The transplant
extension, import/export and bundle/unbundle work equally well here.

Choosing this approach allows 3.x not to carry all of the 2.x
history-since-it-was-branched, meaning the clone is not as big and the
merges not as complicated.


The future of Subversion
------------------------

What happens to the Subversion repositories after the migration?
Since the svn server contains a bunch of repositories, not just the
CPython one, it will probably live on for a bit as not every project
may want to migrate or it takes longer for other projects to migrate.
To prevent people from staying behind, we may want to move migrated
projects from the repository to a new, read-only repository with a new
name.


Build identification
--------------------

Python currently provides the sys.subversion tuple to allow Python
code to find out exactly what version of Python it's running against.
The current version looks something like this:

* ('CPython', 'tags/r262', '71600')
* ('CPython', 'trunk', '73128M')

Another value is returned from Py_GetBuildInfo() in the C API, and
available to Python code as part of sys.version:

* 'r262:71600, Jun  2 2009, 09:58:33'
* 'trunk:73128M, Jun  2 2009, 01:24:14'

I propose that the revision identifier will be the short version of
hg's revision hash, for example 'dd3ebf81af43', augmented with '+'
(instead of 'M') if the working directory from which it was built was
modified.  This mirrors the output of the hg id command, which is
intended for this kind of usage.  The sys.subversion value will also
be renamed to sys.mercurial to reflect the change in VCS.

For the tag/branch identifier, I propose that hg will check for tags
on the currently checked out revision, use the tag if there is one
('tip' doesn't count), and uses the branch name otherwise.
sys.subversion becomes

* ('CPython', '2.6.2', 'dd3ebf81af43')
* ('CPython', 'default', 'af694c6a888c+')

and the build info string becomes

* '2.6.2:dd3ebf81af43, Jun  2 2009, 09:58:33'
* 'default:af694c6a888c+, Jun  2 2009, 01:24:14'

This reflects that the default branch in hg is called 'default'
instead of Subversion's 'trunk', and reflects the proposed new tag
format.


Footnotes
=========

.. [1] The Mercurial book discourages the use of named branches, but
   it is, in this respect, somewhat outdated.  Named branches have
   gotten much easier to use since that comment was written, due to
   improvements in hg.

.. [2] Since the initial working repo is a subset of the archive repo,
   it would also be feasible to pull changes from the working repo
   into the archive repo periodically.


Copyright
=========

This document has been placed in the public domain.



..
   Local Variables:
   mode: indented-text
   indent-tabs-mode: nil
   sentence-end-double-space: t
   fill-column: 70
   coding: utf-8
   End: